News

The ACTA Internet Chapter: Putting the Pieces Together

The Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement negotiations continue in a few hours as Seoul, Korea plays host to the latest round of talks.  The governments have posted the meeting agenda, which unsurprisingly focuses on the issue of Internet enforcement [UPDATE 11/4: Post on discussions for day two of ACTA talks, including the criminal enforcement provisions][UPDATE 11/5: Post on discussions for day three on transparency].  The United States has drafted the chapter under enormous secrecy, with selected groups granted access under strict non-disclosure agreements and other countries (including Canada) given physical, watermarked copies designed to guard against leaks.

Despite the efforts to combat leaks, information on the Internet chapter has begun to emerge (just as they did with the other elements of the treaty). [Update 11/6: Source document now posted]  Sources say that the draft text, modeled on the U.S.-South Korea free trade agreement, focuses on following five issues:

1.   Baseline obligations inspired by Article 41 of the TRIPs which focuses on the enforcement of intellectual property.

2.   A requirement to establish third-party liability for copyright infringement.

3.   Restrictions on limitations to 3rd party liability (ie. limited safe harbour rules for ISPs).  For example, in order for ISPs to qualify for a safe harbour, they would be required establish policies to deter unauthorized storage and transmission of IP infringing content.  Provisions are modeled under the U.S.-Korea Free Trade Agreement, namely Article 18.10.30.  They include policies to terminate subscribers in appropriate circumstances.  Notice-and-takedown, which is not currently the law in Canada nor a requirement under WIPO, would also be an ACTA requirement.

4.   Anti-circumvention legislation that establishes a WIPO+ model by adopting both the WIPO Internet Treaties and the language currently found in U.S. free trade agreements that go beyond the WIPO treaty requirements.  For example, the U.S.-South Korea free trade agreement specifies the permitted exceptions to anti-circumvention rules.  These follow the DMCA model (reverse engineering, computer testing, privacy, etc.) and do not include a fair use/fair dealing exception.  Moreover, the free trade agreement clauses also include a requirement to ban the distribution of circumvention devices.  The current draft does not include any obligation to ensure interoperability of DRM.

5.   Rights Management provisions, also modeled on U.S. free trade treaty language.

If accurate (and these provisions are consistent with the U.S. approach for the past few years in bilateral trade negotiations) the combined effect of these provisions would dramatically reshape Canadian copyright law and to eliminate sovereign choice on domestic copyright policy.  Having just concluded a national copyright consultation, these issues were at the heart of thousands of submissions.  If Canada agrees to these ACTA terms, flexibility in WIPO implementation (as envisioned by the treaty) would be lost and Canada would be forced to implement a host of new reforms (this is precisely what U.S. lobbyists have said they would like to see happen).  In other words, the very notion of a made-in-Canada approach to copyright would be gone.

The Internet chapter raises two additional issues.  On the international front, it provides firm confirmation that ACTA is not a counterfeiting treaty, but a copyright treaty.  These provisions involve copyright policy as no reasonable definition of counterfeiting would include these kinds of provisions.  On the domestic front, it raises serious questions about the Canadian negotiation mandate.  Negotiations from Foreign Affairs are typically constrained by either domestic law, a bill before the House of Commons, or the negotiation mandate letter.  Since these provisions dramatically exceed current Canadian law and are not found in any bill presently before the House, Canadians should be asking whether the negotiation mandate letter has envisioned such dramatic changes to domestic copyright law.  When combined with the other chapters that include statutory damages, search and seizure powers for border guards, anti-camcording rules, and mandatory disclosure of personal information requirements, it is clear that there is no bigger IP issue today than the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement being negotiated behind closed doors this week in Korea.

Update: Further coverage from IDG and Numerama

Update II: InternetNZ issues a press release expressing alarm, while EFF says the leaks "confirm everything that we feared about the secret ACTA negotiations." Electronic Frontiers Australia provides an Australian perspective on the ACTA dangers.

Update III: There are additional articles and postings from around the world (Germany, Italy, Sweden, UK, New Zealand, the Netherlands, U.S., Germany, Italy) as well as coverage from some of the most popular websites (Gizmodo, ReadWriteWeb, TorrentFreak, BoingBoing, Slashdot).

Update IV: See additional posts on Day two of the ACTA talks (Criminal provisions) and Day three (transparency).

306 Comments

  1. If the leaks are accurate
    The treaty cannot be signed by Canada, or if it is signed, it would not necessarily be legal here. You have to wonder what the Canadian negotiators are thinking, if they are in agreement with this? And if they aren’t in agreement with this, why are they not informing their employers, the citizens of Canada?

  2. This closes the loop on government by the corporations. Using this mechanism, corporations can clearly pass laws on the qt, completely bypassing parliament/congress or any form of democratic rule. The original legal mistake was granting corporations the rights of citizens. Now *only* corporations have the rights of citizens.

  3. Maupassant nailed it.
    And this is downright scary.

  4. The U.S. wants to keep this a “secret” because they know it’s wrong.

    Remember all those science fiction books/TV show and movies that paint a very bleak future for the average person, well here another big push towards making fiction into reality.

  5. We must fight this. Loud, Angry, and Physically if needed.
    I’d like to start hearing some very vocal objection from our elected representation. This cannot be allowed to happen.

    Reading through hundreds (of the thousands) of CopyCon submissions, it is clear that Canadian citizens do not want (or need) any such laws. Adopting laws at the whim of private interests is not a good move, socially. Adopting laws drafted by *foreign* private interests is downright insulting and outrageous.

  6. Known Brave says:

    DMCA
    And again, we see that our nice governments are elected to protect corporations and multinationals, against us, taxpaying lowlifes.

    With religion, we were born with the original sin. With laws such as these we will all be born with the original infraction.

    And we vote for these guys?

  7. UncleCounterfeiting says:

    Clear but unclear
    Having done DMCA takedowns in the past, the part described as anti-counterfeiting is actually the DRM part. Copyright takedown notices often word unauthorized copies as counterfeits, even in a digital sense.

    However to the general populace (eg politicians), it will be presented as preventing counterfeit pet food and milk products from china, and this will likely be glossed over.

    Yes, companies do need their trademarks and copyrights respected, but it should be done and paid for by the copyright and trademark owners. Not the government. If people won’t buy their goods at the prices they demand they should go out of business. I want my music, movies and games via digital download, and a way to ensure I can still play then 30 years from now. I know Louis Vuitton’s legitimate purses are still usable in 30 years, so please, the issue is being presented as “all DRMless content is counterfeit”

  8. Jacob Bierma says:

    Whiners!
    Don’t be so stupid all “And again, we see that our nice governments are elected to protect corporations and multinationals, against us, taxpaying lowlifes.” No, sucker. Governements are there to protect the rights of each and every one. You just do not have the right to duplicate art without permission. It is property afterall, made by artists who live on it. That you guys have no money to spend is not the fault of the corporations or multinationals. Let alone of the artists who’s art you are duplicating without permission or paying revenues.

    Also, these laws are not there to protect the multinationals and such, but actually the small companies and artists who are going to be sold online and who just need the money to survive. Nobody should be mad because you copied a cd from a guy with 24 houses and 3 rollses. Well, I would not.

    If you want to have fun for free, go take a shower and find yourself a nice girlfriend.

  9. Transparency
    It is nice to see Transparency on the agenda for Friday, assuming that means what I hope it does.

  10. Dan O'Leary says:

    Not Whiners!
    Your statement “You just do not have the right to duplicate art without permission.” Says everything abut the ignorance of those who profess to say that everyone who copies is stealing… I copy! Yep I copy! Do you know why? Of course you don’t, otherwise you would not be calling us whiners.

    I copy every digital media I purchase so that I have the original if damage occurs. I copy it all to my internal only NAS, so that I can watch or listen to anytime I wish. This is not theft, but just being smart.

    I for one, hope that if something like this ever comes to pass, that we can get a massive amount of people around the world to have a protest where we all attempt to circumvent these draconian DRM crap.

  11. Known Brave says:

    Whiner
    “Nobody should be mad because you copied a cd from a guy with 24 houses and 3 rollses. Well, I would not.”

    With laws like these, you do that, you’re a criminal.

    You record a movie in a theatre, you’re a criminal.

    A dentist, you play music in your waiting room, you have to pay royalties or be a criminal.

    You use a song from a published singer as background music in your YouTube video, you’re a criminal.

    You record a TV show without paying royalties, you’re a criminal.

    They won’t stop.

    There are sufficient laws, right now to protect artists. Adding more and more laws will simply make more criminals and artists won’t get anything more because the public will resent the laws and circumvent them just to protest.

    If you do not feel protected enough, get a box of Trojans. Nice girlfriend optional.

  12. @ Jacob Bierma – Re: Whiners!
    “Governments are there to protect the rights of each and every one.”
    Well then why are they putting the interests of the relatively small number of business owners ahead of the vast majority of individual citizens? If everybody’s rights are to be protected, those of the many should certainly have some bearing above those of the few.

    “You just do not have the right to duplicate art without permission. It is property afterall, made by artists who live on it.”
    Actually, I do have that right in many cases — fair use, for example. Don’t make overbroad claims beyond the *limited* rights granted by copyright.

    No, music and movies are NOT property. They are ideas, or art. There is no physical manifestion of the movie itself. There is a plastic disc which is sold at high margin as a convenient means of distributing that movie/music, however. Unfortunately, the internet has provided much more efficient means of distribution without the need for expensive plastic discs. This should be celebrated, not reprimanded.

    “That you guys have no money to spend is not the fault of the corporations or multinationals. Let alone of the artists who’s art you are duplicating without permission or paying revenues.”
    Actually, I do have lots of money to put towards art and culture. In order to decide where that money should go, though, it is necessary for me to experience as much art as possible. I download movies and music by the bucketloads, and then decide which artists I feel deserve my dollars. I am offering free advertising directly to my own wallet. You would think the creators would be happy about this.

    Don’t get greedy with copyright, or we as a society just might decide to reduce the rights granted so far.

  13. The other issue that people gloss over frequently is that the DMCA-like provisions essentially strip all rights from the consumer. They allow “fair use” only in name only, but practically speaking it doesn’t exist. By granting the rights holder control over the media, and then banning the distribution of circumvention devices, you make it so “fair use” is disallowed and at the sole discretion of the rights holder (who has shown to have zero motivation to allow it). If you can’t break the anti-circumvention measures, you cannot ever exercise your fair use rights.

  14. To Jacob:
    Idealistically I agree with who you say the law should protect, but you are sadly mistaken if you think any of this is to protect the “small companies”. Regardless of whether such a treaty is good or bad law, The fact that this is done with such a high degree of secrecy, and right after “consulting” Canadians on what SOCIETY as a whole wants, and having foreign corporate interests help draft said treaty should tip you off about who this is played out for. If this is for small artists and companies, don’t you think the Canadian gov’t would consult THEM on what they think is best?? In short, your words might have some merit in a utopia, but to call people “Whiners” because of such a gross subversion of democracy (of which this is only one of many) shows you to be nearsighted and uninformed about the issue.

    And just to clear up some of your more ignorant comments: no, not all art is ‘property’; yes, there are many legal instances allowing for making copies; and if “duplicating art” is bad, it should be irrelevant of how rich or poor an artist is. In your view “stealing from artists” as you call it is ok if people have lots of money? What kind of idiotic view is that?

    In short, become a little more informed before spewing off and insulting people. You know old Abe’s saying, “better to remain silent and be thought a fool …”

  15. “companies do need their trademarks and copyrights respected”

    Companies don’t need anything. People need things. Companies are nothing more than tools we create in order to benefit actual human beings. When you talk about the needs of companies, you are treating them as ends, not as means. Then we – human beings – become the means to satisfy their needs.

    Trademark law was NOT created for the benefit of companies. It was created for the benefit of consumers. Similarly, the first modern copyright act, the Statute of Anne, was created “for the encouragement of learning.”

    Your claim should be something more like, “citizens need dependable trademarks so they know what they are getting, and effective copyright that promotes the creation and access to culture and knowledge.”

  16. free
    I borrow books and CDs and DVDs from my local library legally and for free all the time. I can borrow them from friends etc. I can look at them without the artists or the corporations getting anything. What is this you can’t get stuff for free business?

  17. Laurel L. Russwurm says:

    !!!
    Artists don’t benefit from copyright, big corporations do. You know, corporations like Disney who have done their best to control the artists who made it into the monstrous corporate entity they are today. It’s long been rumored that “Uncle Walt” took advantage of his original artist partner, and Walt had to be legally compelled to credit his artists. He thought the only name on the movies should be his. Not because of his artistic talent and input (which dropped off dramatically), but because he owned the company and had the power. But my very favorite is the Peggy Lee story.

    Peggy Lee wrote and sang music for “Lady and The Tramp”. When Disney started making mountains of moolah from new technologies like Video, Peggy Lee had the audacity to sue and won the right to be paid royalties. What did Disney do? They made a point of not re-releasing Lady and the Tramp until AFTER Ms. Lee passed away. What we call copyright today is about corporate control. “Paying the artists” has NEVER been on the Disney agenda, and they are leading the charge…

    Ask Matt Frewer if he’s happy that nobody in the world gets to see him when he was a hot young hunk playing Edison Carter on “Max Headroom” which is not for sale on DVD and will probably be lost to the world forever due to the draconian copyright laws in place NOW. Most artists don’t WANT their work locked up and lost to the sum of human cuture. Artists create to share with audiences. Of course Max Headroom’s content predicted a lot of the things that are happening right now. If this keeps up, we’ll be living in Idiocracy. (See the movie. It’s scary.)

    The worst of it is, audiences will be criminalized for home use and governments will be paying to enforce copyright that isn’t.

  18. Average Joe says:

    Art is already free. It’s been free since the dawn of mankind. Seriously. Ask any artist. It’s already free. It will always be free. Art is about freedom. The freedom to inspire. Everything created today is attributed a copyright, or a government-enforced monopoly. It will not last because art is more powerful than Big Content.

  19. Joe Q Public says:

    Obviously Jacob is a corporate shill. It’s just too bad Obama is as bought and sold as the rest of the politicians on the planet.

  20. World Agreements
    I for one love agreements which put you puny citizens back under the thumb of your corporate dictators!

    YOU WILL OBEY!

    Jacob, you may have an Armband to demonstrate that you are on the proper side of this argument.

  21. Right well I hope they realize this will most likely only increase the amount of people who currently break these ‘laws’. The more things that become caged away from sharing and use without paying a fee each time….the more people will continue to take them without paying. This is also an ironic thing for a Government to do whilst also claiming they have Freedom on their country’s turf.

  22. Motivations
    Do you think any for-profit group cares about the rights of any content producer (artist, musician, coder)?

    All they want is to maximize their profits and if it takes confusing the copyright / counterfeit / bootlegging issues to get governments to pass laws favoring their bottom lines then, that’s what gets gets done.

    @ Jacob

    “If you want to have fun for free, go take a shower and find yourself a nice girlfriend.”

    In my experience, one of those is, the other, most definitely, is not.

  23. jus’ add more fuel to the fire!
    The companies are just doing this because the world is changing. They want to stop the change and grow as fast as they can to offset it. But it just won’t happen: we’re entering a change where people are getting more intelligent, and choosing to be wiser and good, and more caring and loving towards each other. The companies know they’re going down, and are doing anything they can to strenghten their hand over the people. But its a fools dream: greedy and lustful. It’ll just anger people too, once the governments enter this law, proving they’re lined in the company pockets! The governments need a change too, so quickly join the companies, and bring on the fuel, lets grow the fire in the people stronger! get em’ revved – to wallop you!

    http://www.LittleScroll.com

  24. @ Jacob Bierma – Re: Whiners!
    Art is all about copying and re-working previous material.

    Disney is one of the most egregious “thieves” in your universe. The Jungle Book? Stolen from Rudyard Kipling. Pinnochio? Stolen from Carlo Collodi. Cinderella? Stolen from Charles Perrault. It goes on and on.

    The difference now is that Disney wants to lock down copyright in perpetuity, so that their older works can never go back into the Public Domain and contribute to new works and new culture.

    And that is why things like ACTA must be stopped.

  25. Movies and Drugs
    You know, this kind of reminds me of the drug scares that permiate U.S. history. We all know that countless geneerations of getting tough on drugs has given rise to the largest prisoner per capita in the world. Kind of makes me wonder, now that drugs are loosing popularity, is this giong to be another upper class control tool? Who will be able to afford culture once O.T.A. television goes off air? How long before libraries are forced to pay special prices for their movies?

    Just to point out the control some corperations have over our lives, in order to take my “Free shower”, I had to get up and pay the electrical company to turn on my light, I had to walk to the shower in relative warmess, which means gas company for heating, I had to turn on the water, water company, heat the water, gas company, and finally needed to dry myself off with a towel bought at a store. This is not even mentioning the mortgage, the insurence or the property taxs. Thank god most of the utilities are still public. At least that way, some of that money makes it back into circulation. Making the bank of Canada a crown corp… best idea ever. To those Americains out there, sorry about the Federal reserve…

  26. b said the following. I am reposting in case you didn’t read it the first time. Read it now. It is exactly right.
    —————
    The other issue that people gloss over frequently is that the DMCA-like provisions essentially strip all rights from the consumer. They allow “fair use” only in name only, but practically speaking it doesn’t exist. By granting the rights holder control over the media, and then banning the distribution of circumvention devices, you make it so “fair use” is disallowed and at the sole discretion of the rights holder (who has shown to have zero motivation to allow it). If you can’t break the anti-circumvention measures, you cannot ever exercise your fair use rights.
    ——–
    My own comment: Copyright was enacted to encourage the production of artistic products which would in a reasonable period of time go into the public domain. Copyright periods established that the entire artistic product did not go into the public domain until the artist had a chance to make some money off of it.”Fair use” established that the reasonable period was in some instances immediate.

    What is happening now is that copyright is, in effect, being rewritten to be perpetual, and to have no exceptions for fair use. This is being done “under the radar,” through treaties and laws which seem to address legitimate business concerns, so that citizens will not understand what they are losing.

    DRM has, as a practical matter, given corporations the right to abolish fair use of their artistic products. Disney laws have made copyrights perpetual from the point of view of any living human being.

  27. ……
    I run a fairly large art gallery and venue, you had better believe that artists aren’t getting a cut out of this. Very few even make enough money to actually live well, let alone need laws in place to “protect them.”

    The poor artists argument simply doesn’t work. This agreement is about holding onto a shrinking market share as smaller more nimble and dynamic companies who embrace technology and shifting paradigms in the market today. The return of vaudeville is upon us, not to sound too cliche. Artists generally make their money off of sales of original pieces, you can’t copy a canvas and call it an original, simply not possible (well maybe if someone’s dumb enough). Musicians make more money doing shows than they’ll ever do selling CDs. It makes sense that the propagation of information (and art) will benefit those who created it. Look at graffiti artists who give their art away for free every day. Look at Banksy, his art sells for ungodly amounts of money based on the fact that he did it for free.

    In short, it’s a last ditch attempt to not be eaten by piranhas, the smaller dynamic companies, because the dumb lumbering beast fell into the river.

  28. If it were to be true…
    It’s going to be WWIII, but it won’t be just countries vs. countries…it’s citizens vs. corporations. Of course, that’s the very last thing in our minds when it comes to this issue abroad. Then again, these implementations could be ignored just like WIPO in the past. You’ll never know…

  29. Burn it down.
    If our pathetic government’s participation in this CRAPTA isn’t enough to make you all want to burn it to the ground, then we are lost.

    It’s time people. Democracy was never perfect, but there used to be a smidgen of it. We have the tools to build a new direct participatory democracy, where PEOPLE actually have a voice. Delegating decisions to a few is now a complete abject and permanent failure. The few will abuse the many to their minority enrichment, and allow the real mechanisms of our society’s productivity to fall into oblivion while they chase only the fast buck.

    If you want to eat in the future, if you want to communicate freely, if you want anything at all, we have to burn this greed show to the ground and build something honest made truly of and for all of us.

  30. Oh my!
    I am eagerly waiting for the provision about fourth and fifth parties liability! The the whole population of all countries will go to jail! The countries will become just huge gulags!

    Oh, wait,.. there was something like that already in the history of this civilization, wasn’t it?

  31. UncleCounterfeiting says:

    Clear but unclear
    Geof… ”Your claim should be something more like, “citizens need dependable trademarks so they know what they are getting, and effective copyright that promotes the creation and access to culture and knowledge.””

    Yes, exactly.

    What we have now is imports from asian countries that are questionable in nature (go look up the 110 Disney movies-in-a-box from asia) that the average person doesn’t know, or care if it’s counterfeit. The item was not made or authorized by Disney, yet carries all the Disney trademarks and is region free and is of dubious quality. Ironically region locks and CSS do nothing to prevent the purchase and import of such items which have both stripped out. This is the kind of material that ACTA rightfully prohibits in theory.

    But from what’s been leaked so far, suggests that fair use gets eliminated entirely.

  32. What does it matter if you can’t watch Seinfeld re-runs on YouTube?
    There is a lot of noise being generated about this when all we are talking about is media corporations making their crappy products even crappier — if none of us were allowed to watch TV anymore would we die? If copyright owners want to lock down their worthless TV shows, music recordings and movies so that no-one can see them or to make them ridiculously overpriced, then why should we care? They are just shooting themselves in the foot anyway. TV is not a human rights issue. TV is crap. Get a grip.

  33. Kyle clements says:

    the reason this is important
    Len Layton said:
    “What does it matter if you can’t watch Seinfeld re-runs on YouTube?
    … If copyright owners want to lock down their worthless TV shows, music recordings and movies so that no-one can see them or to make them ridiculously overpriced, then why should we care? They are just shooting themselves in the foot anyway. TV is not a human rights issue. TV is crap. Get a grip.”

    It’s not about TV, its about censorship and freedom of expression.
    If I say something on a youtube video, or on my website, or a blog, and someone disagrees with what I say, they can file a copyright complaint against me, and I disappear. I am silenced, my rights to expression have been stripped away under the guise of ‘copyright infringement’. No evidence is needed, no trial is granted, and I am presumed to be guilty by default. The penalty for being merely accused three times is permanent isolation from a large segment of my social sphere, and an inability to promote/advertise/run my business. Unless I find the resources needed to prove my innocence.

    This treaty is a legal abomination. It is a bypass of our democratic process, and a slap in the face to everyone who participated in the recent copyright consultations.

  34. b said the following. I am reposting in case you didn’t read it the first time. Read it now. It is exactly right.
    —————
    The other issue that people gloss over frequently is that the DMCA-like provisions essentially strip all rights from the consumer. They allow “fair use” only in name only, but practically speaking it doesn’t exist. By granting the rights holder control over the media, and then banning the distribution of circumvention devices, you make it so “fair use” is disallowed and at the sole discretion of the rights holder (who has shown to have zero motivation to allow it). If you can’t break the anti-circumvention measures, you cannot ever exercise your fair use rights.
    ——–
    My own comment: Copyright was enacted to encourage the production of artistic products which would in a reasonable period of time go into the public domain. Copyright periods established that the entire artistic product did not go into the public domain until the artist had a chance to make some money off of it.”Fair use” established that the reasonable period was in some instances immediate.

    What is happening now is that copyright is, in effect, being rewritten to be perpetual, and to have no exceptions for fair use. This is being done “under the radar,” through treaties and laws which seem to address legitimate business concerns, so that citizens will not understand what they are losing.

    DRM has, as a practical matter, given corporations the right to abolish fair use of their artistic products. Disney laws have made copyrights perpetual from the point of view of any living human being.

  35. Isn’t it great how people we didn’t elect meet in secret… ah what’s the point? The Nazis have won because people continue to vote the false, left, right paradigm.

  36. Corporatism and Fascism
    Look upp corporatism and fascism on Wikipedia, then go back and read ACTA again. Ask yourself if any of us (myslef voting in Sweden, which too is a democracy the last time I checked) asked our governments to please give up our rights in order to create a fascist state?

    In hindsight it’s no surprise that IFPI was formed in Italy under Moussolini. Old habits never seem to die in the copyright industry…

  37. I’m so angry I wrote a poem:

    Pop. 9,888

    Behold then, under varied awnings
    of all stripes unfolding with whimsy
    despite an August sun dawning
    early over clouds acting clumsy
    and uneven, a few men flock
    past storefronts to just simply gawk
    at the wares behind the windows.

    One particular plain-spoken man
    rolled his eyes about like some token
    set of hills where maidens of Diane
    would hunt naked using oaken
    bows and arrows made from dead gods’ bones
    then the man took out a few stones
    and threw them against the glass.

    Shattering and scattering downward
    as alarms sound in wild amusement
    while the man smashes a foul word
    through a fresh and empty arrangement
    of pure space brought on by the slight
    incongruity that one might
    expect from living in Quicksand.

  38. Missing the point
    I think you are missing a very important point.

    The point is in the wording “accused of” . This would spell the end of legal security and the beginning of total censorship. Everyone could be silenced by *accusing them* of breaking the law. No more freedom of speech.

    In most countries this is unconstitutional.

  39. The law is only for the poor
    GROUPAMA (a large French insurer) was caught in a software PIRACY case of $200m.

    GROUPAMA argued that BANK SECRECY entitled it to limit the scope of Police investigations to a building that was not the place of the infraction.

    And the General Prosecutor of PARIS ruled that it was perfectly legitimate:

    http://remoteanything.com/archives/groupama.pdf

  40. location location location
    anyone know where the one in seoul is being held?
    i want to go protest :D
    email me plz!
    natehitchcock [at] gmail [dot] com

    ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWAH!

  41. location location location
    anyone know where the one in seoul is being held?
    i want to go protest :D
    email me plz!
    natehitchcock [at] gmail [dot] com

    ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWAH!

  42. ACTA must be stopped.

  43. Bill from Tennessee says:

    Master of My Own Universe
    And the Obama administration is pushing this? So…how is that whole “hopey-changey” thing working for YOU guys?

  44. What might a good agreement be?
    What “ought” the law and treatises say? The problem seems to stem from the present separation between the desires of the author of a work and those in control of the rights associated with it.

    Suggestion:
    All purchases of patents and copyright are banned. Only the author can decide on its disposition. This to include that restrictive contracts with authors are also prevented, so no more exclusive rights agreements.

    That way the author really can decide how they want to utilise their work, and do it on each individual application for repeat use if it is digital in format. It’s up to them to make those choices in each case.

    If they want to make it clear, then there should be a method of easily adding suitable terms to the work itself. This is how the GPL can manage the desires of the writers of software by including the necessary wording in the item itself.

    I really think it is the responsibility of the author to determine the distribution of their own work – and no one else’s.

  45. Fascism should more appropriately be called Corporatism because it is a merger of state and corporate power. – Benito Mussolini
    Add the words global in there and I think you have ACTA.

    Special thanks to the US backers of corporate greed for forcing this affront to democracy down the throats of the World’s citizens.

    Seig Heil Y’all

  46. What about CC?
    I wonder what this will do to Creative Commons content… with such draconian measures coming in, will it drive more artists towards CC and coders to GPL?

  47. There is always a reaction
    Have any of the previous laws worked or actually produced results? When the Pirate Bay was shut down, hundreds of smaller sites popped up almost instantly to replace it. Inevitably, the true enforcement of this will end up shutting down so many users — legitimate and non-legitimate — that high-profile sites like Youtube will lose viewership. Does anyone else realize how much money Youtube makes? Ultimately, this means corporations will not necessarily be robbing the people, but other corporations as well. Many people will not use the internet much at all, which will harm ISPs and ad companies. Many artists will move to creative commons licenses so their music gets heard. Otherwise, it won’t be heard.

    I think this will end up creating the new market of content without intending to do it. Every time these guys try to put a new law in place, it just gets circumvented. Draconian measures, as often as people try to pass them, don’t make it out. They will always find some sympathetic judge that will rule it unconstitutional. There are ALREADY judges that find our current DRM laws unconstitutional, so the idea that this would ever be enforced is ridiculous.

  48. Media and copyright
    We have gone so long now where we realize that movies and music Albums are not worth $15 to $40 that we as a society are not turning back. If you take away every form of free medium distribution, you will not find us flocking back into stores to buy $25 DVDs or Blu-Rays that paradigm is dead. You will find us creating our own free content and enjoying the free content created by others.

  49. donde esta documento? “If accurate” doesn’t lend a lot of credibility. Are the leaks being withheld because of the document watermarking? Is it all verbal?

  50. Look it up
    Welcome to the beginning of the North American Union.

  51. Not quite
    First, a lot of people here bring up our democracy as being a protection against these sorts of laws and treaties. You poor deluded fools. We don’t live in a democracy. We live in a republic, a republic were the representatives are chosen by how much money they can accumulate to wage their campaigns and by how charismatically they can present themselves. There’s no real examination of their qualifications. It might be nice if the people running for office were really put through a real hiring/qualification process before they were even presented for election. Anyway, once they’re elected they’ll do just as they please especially if it improves their bottom line.

    Given that situation, should anyone really be surprised that the representatives take the positions espoused by the bodies that can afford to buy them?

    Now, back to copying, everything on the net is not there because the copyright holder put it there. There are vast quantities of movies, music, art and literature that are there because someone other than the copyright holder put it there and they or someone else or both are making money from it’s dissemination. Whether that’s the minority or majority of the content on the net doesn’t matter, it’s just the idea that someone is making money from someone else’s work that drives all this concern. If there were a perfect DRM that would let me buy a movie or a piece of music and play it from any device for the rest of time, I think I’d be pleased as punch but the copyright holders would still be concerned. As an example, the movie comanies were afraid, when VHS came out, that someone would buy a tape and then invite a friend over to watch it. They called that an “unpaid viewing” and that extends to the music in the dentist’s office and the cartoon playing in the barber shop when the kids are waiting to have their hair cut and the lady that sang as she stacked products on store shelves. All unpaid viewings or hearing of someone’s work.

    The only thing that can be counted on is that as hard as the rights holders try to tighten the screws on the common people, the harder the common people will make it to control them. As soon as they come up with a viable DRM with good fair use provisions and price their products reasonably, there won’t be the need for criminalizing every other person in the world.

  52. Content has destroyed us anyways…
    We have no culture. We were raised by Disney. We enjoy what they say is the top 40 list of the week. We have lost the ability to think and create on our own. All we do is share someone else’s ideas. Yes, with these laws, most of us will be called criminals, we do copy everyone else, but in the end, as someone else pointed out, it will save us and force us to create again. They are just sealing their own coffin, and igniting us to fight for our lives. We don’t want or need their works anymore. We have the ability to make new tools, and to simply claim the power from the minority. Every officer and soldier is a citizen, and has a family. Eventually they will have to make a decision as a human. We must all fight our own fight, and do the right thing when the time comes. Traditions of the past always die and create ground for the new. It is the genesis of life. Those that fight the truth will crash against the rocks and be scattered.

  53. this is an affront to humanity
    Anyone read any Shadowrun a few years ago? corporations rule, governments are non-existent, and megacorps rule.

    we need to act to prevent this atrocity.
    it is an affront to human freedoms, and free speech.

  54. @Brendan said: We must fight this. Loud, Angry, and Physically if needed.
    “Adopting laws drafted by *foreign* private interests is downright insulting and outrageous.”

    In an extreme view, it shows that the Canadian Government is nothing but a puppet state, casually tossing aside the 1867 BNA Act. Chief Justice Sir Edward Coke is certainly rolling over in his grave. Maybe fortunately, the Supreme Court (as it stands now) would squash it and they would have a lot to say if ever something like this did go through unabated.

    Some advice for Harper and company, they should look up the meaning of “Sovereignty”.

  55. Internet MIGHT work
    As an example of the type of control a telcom company can have on the net,

    Lets take videotron for example, owned by quebecor, a media publishing company. Lets have a look at what kind of control they have over the internet.

    First, the limit, 60gb a month. 10 regular dvd`s from netflix. We wont’ even talk blue ray. Of course, can`t allow more then that, could bump into their videotron movie rental store sales. (That`s if you don’t do anything other downloading)

    Next, many quebec shows are created by Quebecor, and, oddly enough, most of these shows are only streamable on a videotron connection. But you know, that’s faire, they created it, they can limite it’s audience however they want.

    However, if you dare downloading something that isin’t videotron, and someone else has a problem with it, they will not only happily hand over your peronal information associated to your ip, but, release a statement that they fully support the actions of any lawsuites that may ensue. Oh, and don’t worry about that pesky courte stuff, they won’t even show up to listen to the official arguments as to why this company is trying to sue.

    Now lets say, you’re not happy with all these limitations. Especially the part where they automaticly bill you for over usage without notification. You want cable, but, do not want videotron. Well, tough luck, because as with other cable co’s they own the coaxial line coming into your home. So no matter what happens, they still get a peice of the pie and, if they feel that their network is too congested by your none 60gb downloading, they can now, according to crtc, throttle you. P.S., good luck finding an independent cable isp in gatineau. If they do open up their networks to competition, they must be very, very small companies to be almost impossible to find. In the end, they do get to decided who can use their network and who cant.

    Now, with this nice dedicated tax payer subsidized network, they add home phone service. Essentially voip, however, with dedicated pipes. Want Primus? It’s got to share the main congested network. Power outages, since they have this nice reserved network, with gateways plugged directly into these power supported lines, no router to speak of, you now have reliable 911 safety. For all other voip customers, too bad.

    Lastly, for our conveniance, a green box is placed at every second house. This ugly little thing makes sure the cable guy can quickly connect, or disconnect, your cable and your neighbors. A single box for the entire neighborhood in a public place? Hell no, amplifiers are too expensive. Instead it provides a young healthy dose of electromagnetic radiation to the poor sap’s kids who’s lawn just seem to preoccupy the space around their box. Does he even have cable at his home? No choice, you get a box.

  56. Regulations, regulations, regulations
    if you americans had enough regulatory mechanisms to curb the political influence of the corporations, all this lobbying, law buying and grand betrayal wouldnt happen. some of you are STILL insistent on ‘deregulation’, and stuck in an 19th century capitalist mindset. this is what happens when you deregulate… allow corporations run amok… they set up lobbying and you get your butt handed over to you.

  57. Paul Schlegel says:

    This seems alarming to me. However, I brought it up in another forum and someone claimed that the takedown issues were “nothing to worry about” because “it’s illegal to file a false takedown report…anyone doing it will find themselves in a jam in a hurry.”

  58. Who cares
    They don’t need to pass this crap, like >1 million a year isn’t enough? Lots of people pirate stuff just because they can’t afford it. Then you have people like the guys above saying “they’re just trying to make a living”. OK! Let’s do that with everyone, “everyone has a 75,000$ ceiling for wages!”
    ONLY THAT would make all this worthwhile, otherwise, the gov is just supporting the ones who have the money to make the strong-arm plays…
    wtf are we gonna do about it? nothing.
    But get shit for free still.

  59. Zacqary Adam Green says:

    Where’s the leaked document?
    Do you have a link? I want to read this thing.

  60. Caped salaries
    I like the idea of caped salaries. It would definitly curb many wealth concentration on many levels. Money is only a trading tool as long as it’s acutally available for trade. It would have to be combined with some crazy foreigne ownsership policy and some regulations against multi national corps, othwerwise, they’ll just find a border to move across and continue concentrating their wealth there. Tell me, what’s the point of having multiple billions if you’re only going to use one or two in your life time? What a wast of depreciation

  61. Computers are illegal
    Did you know that a computer to properly function must make at least 2-3 copies of its software? How can it be legal to use a computer, if the bits of the software stored on its hard disk are copied into memory? And then they are copied into the processor cache memory? And then they are copied into the processor registers to be executed? Let’s sue Intel and Dell and Apple and all computer manufacturers which create such intrinsically illegal devices!!!

  62. Painting themselves into corners.
    The point all of you noobs forget is THIS WILL ONLY APPLY TO WORKS COVERED BY COPYRIGHT OR PATENT! It amazes me that people are so easily duped sometimes! Piss you off a little and all objectivity leaks from between your ears in rage. When you were a kid, and trying to figure out what friends you wanted to hang out with, one of the ways you determined this was by how high a price to your person and reputation you would have to pay for the association. Some groups required rites of passage, others that you participate in group-think, mob-action, tribute, or sacrifice. The only way to avoid paying any of these was to deny them all.

    The same concept applies here. In order to avoid paying for crap, download and consume works from people not trying to extort you for every view, game or listen. Purchase such goods only if YOU feel the artist produced something worthy of the ask-price. ie. DON’T PLAY WITH THE KIDS WHO WANT TO ASS-RAPE YOU FOR NOT PAYING THEM EVERY TIME YOU COPY, WATCH, OR LISTEN TO THEIR WORKS!!! =PROBLEM SOLVED.

    Put your products out on the web. Price them fairly, make a quality product, and you won’t have to worry too much about piracy.

  63. People still have power
    People seem to forget that most of what they complain about with large corporations can be dealt with a simple old method…boycott. Wikipedia definition: A boycott is a form of consumer activism involving the act of voluntarily abstaining from using, buying, or dealing with a person, organization, or country as an expression of protest, usually for political reasons.

    I could go on and on about how this could be applied in so many situations I hear/read people complaining about. In general, when it comes to these companies doing things you don’t like, find out their affiliations and cut out everything you can that has anything to do with them. Don’t like the way your representation in government is acting/performing, be vocal about why and make sure you vote.
    Sure, it can be a little rough, you may even have to do without something you like for a while. Fact is that complaining is not going to do ANYTHING. Until all the “little guys” around the world are willing to take action and make sacrifices, things really won’t change. You want to make a difference in matters like this, hit these people where it hurts…don’t give them your money, don’t give them your vote, and tell others what u are doing and why.

  64. for the lulz says:

    Canadians
    Crazy Canadians :p

  65. TBone At Large
    The internet leads us to the new world order…

  66. some dude
    If you’re upset because you can no longer copy things and will have to buy them, I don’t feel bad for you. Obviously someone spent money making it, and whether or not you believe it is right, that’s the way society works. However, I do not believe this is the business of the government. They should stay the hell away from this. If you want to put out some DRM, fine, you deal with the market and consumer implications of it. If you want to go DRM free, you also have to deal with the implications of that.

    These implications are very complex, and extend far beyond file sharing sites. They extend to people spreading good or bad word of mouth about you, and they affect customers returning or not. In no way shape or form, however, is it the governments job to enforce the business model of any business. I mean if they decide that you cannot copy it, then they should distribute it in a way that doesn’t allow you to do so. If someone figures out how to break it, either release an update, or forget your precious protection. It’s not the governments job to make sure the citizens are only using something as the creator of it has intended. That’s ridiculous. Would you allow Ford to tell you which roads you’re allowed to drive on?

    Anyway, I don’t believe in stealing things one ought to pay for, but I also think that the government is not here to make sure that you don’t copy art or software. It’s well enough to prevent bodily harm, and whatever, but making sure someone has the right intentions when they click the play button is far out of that scope of authority.

  67. truthseeker1neo says:

    nickel and dime me to death
    just another piece of legislation brought about by the NWO to cause unrest with the rest of the population.

  68. Crosbie Fitch says:

    At some point
    At some point everyone who believed the fairy tale that the 18th century privilege of copyright was a reward to the citizen for their creativity, will realise that it was actually the favour to the press of endorsing their de facto cartel/monopolies in exchange for the press remaining subject to the state.

    It’s time to realise that copyright is the name of your cultural manacles that you’ve been wearing with pride for far too long. ACTA is simply reinforcing their locks.

    I’d stop wearing them altogether if I were you.

    Abolish copyright.

  69. And this is what our government is going to do after the copyright consultation, in spite of an absolutely overwhelming voice against prohibitions on circumventing DRM when done for otherwise legal reasons. This proposal is everything I feared would happen to copyright in Canada… and worse.

  70. Not Whiners (again)
    Quote:
    {{{Whiner
    “Nobody should be mad because you copied a cd from a guy with 24 houses and 3 rollses. Well, I would not.”

    With laws like these, you do that, you’re a criminal.

    You record a movie in a theatre, you’re a criminal.

    A dentist, you play music in your waiting room, you have to pay royalties or be a criminal.

    You use a song from a published singer as background music in your YouTube video, you’re a criminal.

    You record a TV show without paying royalties, you’re a criminal.

    They won’t stop.

    There are sufficient laws, right now to protect artists. Adding more and more laws will simply make more criminals and artists won’t get anything more because the public will resent the laws and circumvent them just to protest.

    If you do not feel protected enough, get a box of Trojans. Nice girlfriend optional. }}}

    Actually, doesn’t this really say that artists will not be going towards companies to record/publish/sell their music? Artists themselves are against this – this is only the wish of huge movie and music publishers, who are in turn egged on by MPAA/RIAA and lawyers who have studies only copyright law, and have nothing else they can do to pay their increasingly large gas bills for their Visa-owned BMW.

    Hopefully, artists will finally give the coup-de-grâce to companies worldwide, when they understand that this can only lead to implosion unto itself.

    FREE MOVIES FREE MUSIC FREE ART IT’S MEANT TO BE

  71. Brian from Pennsylvania says:

    The Media Bubble
    This treaty is just the most recent manifestation of media conglomerates being lazy. Specifically, they are unwilling to relinquish the artificially high prices they have demanded for almost a century, but without rational justification. From a lazy, greedy perspective, this is completely understandable. However, with the aid of the internet, people have realized that the value of media has been completely overinflated. For example, why is an actor’s performance worth $20,000,000 if someone on Youtube is willing to entertain 60 million people for free? Why are major record labels claiming albums cost millions of dollars to produce when several hundred thousand musicians on Myspace produce music of equal or higher quality for a few hundred bucks (at most)? Why should we pay out hundreds of dollars a year for printed news material when bloggers are willing to pursue unbiased coverage for free? The Media Bubble is going to burst sooner than later.

    The Media Bubble exists because media no longer have intrinsic value: 1) media are endlessly reproducible with identical high fidelity 2) there are enough people willing to make their own creative content for free that it is not economically viable to charge the prices that media conglomerates are used to. This treaty is a last-ditch effort to keep media distribution in the hands of the rich, corporate, few. They will fail because, simply, the public has learned that it can sufficiently entertain itself: anyone can now experience the fame of a movie star, rock star, Disney cartoonist, best selling author, without the overhead or distribution costs.

    Thankfully, it doesn’t matter whether this treaty passes or not, because it’s already too late: it is not the technology or the infrastructure that is maintaining the new media movement, it is the altered mindset of ordinary people. Technology and infrastructure were necessary to catalyze the information age, but the implications for creative content will persist independently. As information grows more and more linked, no single idea will have value: its physical representation will be the only thing finite, and hence, valuable. That will be a sufficient avenue for media to be sustainable (live performances, integration with craft (merchandise), unique affectations, personal touches, etc.).

    In other words, Big Media needs to catch up or go *Pop!* like weasels.

  72. LOL
    LOLOLOLOLOLOL we are all getting fucked up the pooper once again !!

    Thank you corporate america !!

  73. This is how global pulic policy is made: in secret and with no concern for totalitarianism
    Wayne asked: “if [Canadian negotiators] aren’t in agreement with this, why are they not informing their employers, the citizens of Canada?”

    Your ideas are quaint and olde-fashioned, Wayne. These “employees” of ours can’t do what you ask because the negotiations are actually clandestine operations conducted by industry. These sorts of secret negotiations only make use of the services of bought and paid for “public sector” workers. The public sector has been made meek by cushy pensions and benefits and is naturally compliant since most do not speak English as a first language (including Canada where many federal employees struggle with English since they primary language of thought is French), they have scarily large mortgages, are desperate to retain their jobs, and are in *way* over their heads on almost any issue. Critical thinkers like Professor Geist and/or his students are not eligible for public sector jobs and would quite likely not want them in any case.

    With increasing digitization, the extra-legal seizure of your digital assets (family photos, banking and financial data, documents, communications) by unthinking and unaccountable “border guards” is going to prove to be very inconvenient for people. And do not expect border guards to understand why you might want to encrypt your personal information …

  74. loveyourgovernment says:

    PLEASE HELP US STOP ALL THIS !!!

  75. yet again another brilliant move by the Obama administration

  76. DuddleyFuddle says:

    I have been ‘boycotting’ mondo corporation for some time now. I have ditched Bell completely for Vonage for the better part of this decade. I have ditched Direct Energy, then cut off Enbridge and gone to all electric for three years. The ‘$40′ I was paying for just being hooked up to gas more than offsets increased heating costs. I have dropped Rogers cable tv and Look tv and internet for Rogers slowest internet – 2 years now. I will be dropping Rogers altogether soon for Velcome. Rogers can come to my house and pick up their rental modem if they so wish. I’m not returning it to my local Rogers store. I have dropped my Virgin pay-as-you-go cell with a $15 topup every three months because Bell bought out Virgin and went to one month topup. Goodby Bell. I am paying down all my credit cards with the sole purpose of paying them off. I am not buying take out foods or processed foods of any kind. I am learning to prepare nutritious meals, candies, confections of my own making. I buy only micro-brewed ales. I will never buy a car again on credit. My most recent car was purchased with cash. I am making a conscious effort not to buy any product or service from any large corporation (banks, insurance co’s, fast food, retailing, content provider, ISP, newspaper, utility, etc. etc) wherever possible for locally produced services and goods. I am promoting my ideas amongst friends and family with varying degrees of success. I have been feeling very good with what I’m doing.

  77. Freudian title misread
    “The ACTA Internet Chapter: Putting the Feces Together”

    I don’t know whether to laugh or to cry….

  78. Joke
    Did you know that 90% of people when their car is about to hit the ditch say, “Oh shit.” The rest are from Canada. We say “Hold my beer and watch this.”

    I probably owe somebody money for that now.
    :)

  79. Google
    I’d like to hear Google and Obama’s take on this issue.

  80. To Ozlanthos
    Hey ‘noob’, my (main) problem isn’t what’s in ACTA, it’s the fact that it’s being MADE IN SECRET WITH FOREIGN INTERVENTION. Get it? Know what sovereignty means? If our government wants to consult its own citizens on something and then make a decision in conjunction with, y’know, the people who voted them in, then I’m pretty open-minded. But making ANY treaties in secrecy from public viewing is wrong, I don’t care if it’s to do with jaywalking. Get it? I can’t quite figure out why this simple fact escapes some people. Why not let your mechanic pick the next car you buy, he knows more about cars than you, right? He has no other vested interests, right?

    Same to the rest of the shills out there. If you think your position on something is so ‘right’ and ‘moral’, then have the guts to stand behind it. Instead we get a bunch of American lobbyists hanging out in the shadows and a freaking copyright/counterfeit treaty classified as secret due to national security. What a joke. Funny, I don’t remember seeing any American corporations printed on the ballot when I voted in the last federal election …

  81. We’re not going to hold them…
    We’re going to hang them.

  82. I have no love for what they are doing to strip consumers of any ability to enjoy fair dealing or personal use privileges, but for people who would advocate abolishing copyright, I have but one simple question: What would you propose as an alternative, that would actually be effective in today’s climate, both in terms of commercial value and in terms of what would motivate artists to continue to create?

    Sure, people made creative works before copyright, but back then it was difficult for people who weren’t authorized by the creator of the work to get away with it… copying was tedious, error-prone, and expensive.

    Today, copying is so cheap a five-year old can do it at a push of a button.

    So one might not wonder why not do away with publishers, and let everybody self-publish instead? While that’s just fine and dandy, even that proposed model will not work without the protections of copyright. If a lesser known individual creates a work, and attempts to self-publish, a larger corporate entity with a wider distribution capacity could potentially take over that publishing from him, without offering the original creator any compensation. People would not directly associate the work with the lesser known individual, and would instead associate it (wrongly) with the organization that took over publishing from the creator without the creator’s consent or approval. With copyright, at least the creator of the work can take some legal recourse against a company that would do this… without any copyright, exactly what would stop this from happening?

  83. iCEkOLDsOLE says:

    ‘the government is there to protect our rights.”
    The governmnet did protect our individual rights, when it was still somehow beneficial to do so. That is obviously no the case any longer. Look at the worlds current economic status, it sucks; no jobs, no money, no social services – nothing. I live in the crummy state of Virinia. I am unemployed, and facing a horrible job market I returned to college to futher my education and find a better job. I still planned to work while attending school, but there are no jobs. I reluctantly went to the swocial services office to apply for some food stamps, but because I attend an institute for higher education, the only way I am eligible for such services is to either drop out of school or work a madatory twenty hours each week. They fail to see the fact that had I been able to work twenty hours each week I would not be applying them in the first place! But, were I to drop out, I’d have no problem being given food stamps. It’s a blatant policy aimed at keeping the public stupid, so they don’t feel empowered to speak out against obvious disregard to individual rights.

    US government officals need to be reminded that the offices they hold are an honor, not an entitlement, as is the basis for our entire democracy; we’re a republic not a dictatorship. It is amazing how quickly those elected to represent us, and our opinions never seem to take a moment as ask our thoughts anymore. Giant corporations like AIG and Chase Manhatten, to name just a couple, can be total cluster-fucks, spending themselves to the point of a global finacial collapse, and then be handed free money to do it all over again – nothing more than a fatherly pat on back and a few words of encouragement for punishment! $787 billion dollars, no questions asked. Yet, I cannot find work after losing my job with a bailed out company and have no recourse or hope of any help with all the money I have paid in taxes. Social services are not free – I’ve paid for them for years, thinking that if god forbid I need them they’d be there. was wrong.

    These new internet laws don’t suprise me in the least. I wondered how long it would take for something like this to happen. Civil rights are going to be a thing of the past in ten or fifteen years, so enjoy them while you have them. Instead of the pledge of alliegance said by school children, elected officals should have to say a pledge of responsiblity and appreciation to be surving the greater good our society.

  84. they want total control
    Obama and his Marxist minions want more laws to control that which has grown and thrived without them. Sooner or later, there will be a “fairness” doctrine for the internet too, once they get the internet under the FCC’s thumb via the so-callled “net neutrality” goal. Their true goal is control over the masses which, for now, are communicating too freely for their liking.

  85. Thinking myself says:

    Don’t believe everything you watch on TV…
    From Wikipedia’s Climate_change_consensus page: “It seems that the debate on the authenticity of global warming and the role played by human activity is largely nonexistent among those who understand the nuances and scientific basis of long-term climate processes.”

    Read e.g. Wikipedia’s Greenhouse_effect page if you don’t believe that “Carbon dioxide is the human-produced greenhouse gas that contributes most of radiative forcing from human activity.”

    It is true that the sun affects earth’s temperature, but that does not mean humans aren’t warming our planet up in addition to that and that global warming is indeed true and action need to be taken. Don’t spread the FUD. Think. We have only one planet.

    Corporate control is bad and it might be true that someone might be trying to take e.g. global warming and benefit from it the wrong way. But that does not mean global warming isn’t true and happening right now. Don’t mix things up in your mind.

  86. copyright is a government endorsed monopoly on a certain product. it is intended to encourage innovation and the advancement of the useful arts and sciences for the benefit of society.

    tell me what’s more useful or beneficial to our society? the last 70 years worth of humanity’s collective artistic and scientific creations available at the click of a mouse to anyone who wishes to tinker, reshape, extract, derive, learn, copy, or reinvent?

    or all of it. every single last literary, musical, and artistic achievement locked in the vault of the rightsholder. available only at a price set by the whim of the rightsholder.

    i’m not an advocate of an abolition on copyright. i am an advocate of *drastically* reduced durations. 5-7 years tops. i’d be happier with 2-3.

    this cloak and dagger approach to solidifying the positions of multi-national publishing conglomerates over the collected treasures of humanity’s artistic achievements is, simply, an outrage. it’s beyond infuriating. it signifies all that is wrong with corporate greed and corrupt governments. and i’m absolutely convinced we’ll see 90% of this garbage enacted in these treaties. because we’re powerless to stop it.

  87. Harper continues to buy American
    It’s not surprising that the Canadian negotiators don’t seem too anxious to protect our sovereign interests. They get their direction from PM Harper who is quite happy to sellout Canada to the US at any cost.

  88. Average Joe says:

    Copyright lasts way too long. There are cases where a long dead artist has no living heirs but someone has to look after the estate, how about some coporate trust, sure, money can be made after all. 90 years after the art was created, 70 years after the artist has died and some corporation who “owns” the rights is making $500,000 a year licensing the work to public schools.

    That’s asinine. Copyright lasts too long.

  89. Anonymous Coward says:

    Public Domain
    The public domain is a vital component to the arts and the various entertainments to a great many people all the world over. It’s a shame that the public domain doesn’t seem to have a representative at these secret talks. The public domain, you know, that collection of all our world’s art and knowledge.

    Just sitting there, waiting for more art and culture and entertainment and science and invention and knowledge to help it grow. Waiting to be copied. And copied. And copied. Waiting to be shared. And shared. And shared.

    Good luck with trying to control the internet!

  90. I don’t think there is any secret negotiation to enforce laws internationally to forbid the hiding of revenues from big corporation to prevent them to pay there due income taxes. There is thousand of billion of money hidden in fiscal paradises around the world. I did not see yet any government with enough ball to attack those laws, to rule the fiscal evasion in fiscal paradises. But when the people try to hide from big corporation some revenue then the secret negotiations begins. Different rules different power. It is close the time of the physical revolution by people if governments are not taking their employer seriously(We, the people, are paying for our government employees).

  91. BOO
    Barack Obscene Obama,

    mmmmmmm mmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

  92. lose basic gun rights, then all other so called rights become illusions to be lost at whim
    You canucks gave up your gun rights. These were basic human rights. By giving them up voluntarily you identified yourselves as little better than potential slaves to be exploited at whim by anyone. Now the exploiters have again come as mathematically certain they would. You are defenseless wimps. You deserve nothing better than slavery, serfdom, or other servitude as being defenseless you are also worthless. Until and unless you get back your gun rights, you will continue to go downhill. The hill is long and gets steeper and slipperier as you go further down. Fascism is at the bottom. And war. Then you, too, can have mournful crosses to your war dead in every town, just like Germany. For when the war comes, the exploiters will you YOU as cannon fodder to wage it.

  93. Father
    Rollerball!

    The movie that displays corporate powers run amuck.

    Now Rollerball becomes reality. Not far until 1984 shows up.

  94. hardtimes989 says:

    1984 take over
    Folks welcome to the new world order . I heard its getting really bad in the UK read some news articles they have started watching people in their own homes. starting with 200 families, security cameras in their house , they say its to make sure the children get to bed on time, have proper meals and get to school on time. Yeah right children my ass they are using this as an excuse to watch people like a 1984. Hell what do you think the obama health care plan is all about ? Common since should tell you its another government take over liek he is doing with teh internet now. He will eventually get rid of all other Private insurance etc. his plan will be the only choice after so long. and he will make it where you will have to have an RFID chip or you will not be allowed medical treatment .

    Read your bible people . In the right hand or forehead, they already have the RFID chip in peoples right hand for buying drinks in night clubs in Spain . It’s only a matter of time till the dollar goes completely dead , what do you think is gonna replace that dollar as the new world reserve currency ? The dollar collapse was engineered by the bankers . Their ultimate goal is to get every man,woman and child implanted with an RFID microchip to track your ever move. Its the mark of the beast Just like the bible described . and its happening right in front of our eyes

  95. Moral Panic
    This seems scary. Morally deplorable!
    Are we feeding a moral panic of our own? should we be?

  96. Seriously?
    @BOBO, @free4now, @lynn, etc.

    Turn the Fox news off and think for a moment. It’s the American corporatocracy that has caused this; not Obama or any of the other puppets you had a chance to “elect”, nor is it Canada’s preference for not flooding our country with guns (I can only imagine the mental gymnastics it took to come up with THAT one). So long as your politicians are for sale, and for so long as our politicians allow themselves to be bullied by their counterparts to the south we will see more of this.

    To quote a great man, “it’s called the American dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.”

  97. The chief US negotiator for ACTA is the former Time Warner Vice President for Global Public Policy, and before that, she was a lobbyist for Ely Lilly, the pharmaceutical company.

    http://www.keionline.org/blogs/2009/06/25/kira-alvarez

  98. Matthew Skala says:

    Don’t feed the troll
    We’ve got enough real problems here that it’s not worth wasting attention under the bridge.

  99. Wesley Parish says:

    Cementing China’s economic leadership
    You realize that China, without all this hoo-haa over unenforceable copyrights and patents slowing everything down and dragging everything down, is going to be twice the economic powerhouse it was previously.

    Talk about abdication – “Little Black Bag” and Angie, by Cyril Kornbluth, anyone?

  100. This isn’t a copyright issue. More-so an angle in controlling the flow of information.

  101. Serious Problems
    Robert:

    It has everything to do with the previous U.S. administration, the current one, AND the special interests that control this U.S. nation. Our founders tried so hard to avoid this scenario and the happy progressives of the early 1900′s did everything they could to make sure it would all change. It’s corruption like this that had our founders set up the vote of the people, the vote of the states, and the vote of the nation, and why the progressives changed that in our 17th constitutional amendment.

    We have a major problem here. The internet is the ultimate example of the closest thing to a free market the world has ever seen, and look how quickly it’s exploded around this planet. This is simply a way to control the masses, and it’s time the masses say I’m mad as hell and I’m not going to take it anymore.

  102. Obama’s claim of National Security
    I would like to understand what roles in National Security do the top executives of large copyright control corporations play? Some time ago was published a list of people who are instrumental in creating ACTA and a large number of them are in the business of copyright control. I would really like to understand how copyright and national security have any connection at all.

  103. rollingeyes says:



    Some time ago was published a list of people who are instrumental in creating ACTA and a large number of them are in the business of copyright control.

    Who did you think they’d send to these trade agreement talks? Chefs? Mimes? This is like complaining that the AA meeting you attended was full of people with an alcohol problem…

  104. Bureaucrats like to create jobs for bureaucrats. So now national borders don’t matter any more.

  105. If this were about protecting the artists
    it would be impossible for the artist/author to assign the copyright or its benefits to any other entity. All contracts would have to have some other, less-exploitative basis.

  106. While sending my position of outrage to the Senate, Congress and President Obama, I couldn’t help but notice this line of BS on the White House’s website: President Obama is committed to creating the most open and accessible administration in American history.

    We are being lied to….again…over and over….this is not “change I can believe in”.

  107. northern New York
    Many seemingly well thought-out comments here. My hope for the future is that things will always seem far worse than may be factual. Still, there is a time coming that will take many by shocked surprise. The good news is that only individuals can do anything about it.

    Come, Lord Jesus.

  108. Ohhhh please pass it!
    It would be the last bullet the idiots will shoot themselves with
    Not only will the whole world resist this and it would be impossible to implement
    Free and Open source software would become the only alternative at the expense of old style copyright business models and media
    Which will totally kill copyright
    I bet even Bill Gates would have nightmares if they see this article
    I dare them to pass this!

  109. National Security!?!
    The only reason this would anything to do with national security is the fact that someone out there is posting information that the ‘powers that be” do not want distributed. In other words, political dissent. Quote a politician making some asinine statement that is an obvious attempt to stomp on the rights of those who elected him…he claims your post/article/website is a copyright infringement. Boom! There goes your site. No judge, no jury. Just an accusation. Oh you want some information on medical issues that do NOT involve taking Pharmaceutical products, as in theraputic levels of vitamins/supplements, and those sites quote information/studies from the CDC or FDA or even the ACTUAL studies (not the spun conclusions) the Pharmaceutical have released…Boom! Accusation of copyright infringement because you quoted a line/paragraph from their study…Bye Bye to your site.

    What better way to quell distribution of unwanted information than by claiming everything not agreeing with your view is a copyright infringement. The financial and political motivation to do so is HUGE.

  110. Remember that Simpsons Episode?
    Whenever I read these things, I’m reminded of Grandpa Simpson being hassled by lawyers for “unauthorized imitations” of Charlie Chaplin.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lady_Bouvier's_Lover#Cultural_references

  111. Andrei Mincov says:

    ACTA may not be perfect
    ACTA may not be perfect, but an imperfect ACTA is better than no ACTA.
    The harm from current worldwide IP infringement is much greater than potential dangers of censorship.
    Internet age is probably the time when we need stronger copyright laws most.
    The biggest danger would be to create a general “public benefit” exception to copyright.
    I hope this never happens.

    As for ACTA, again, piracy must be curtailed as strictly as possible. No efficient enforcement is possible on the Internet unless all ISPs are legally required to cooperate to a certain degree with IP owners.

  112. Dan O'Leary says:

    “ACTA may not be perfect” < ?
    Well, I guess you don’t really understand the issues or the impact. Laws already exist to convict people of stealing, or profiting from other peoples works. Enforce these laws, INSTEAD of making fair use a crime. Like I said in an earlier post, I for one will ALWAYS makes copies of my DVDs and CDs so that I have backups. I will also place digital copies onto my MP3 player, my NAS (for streaming to my TV). This is fair use. If ACTA happens, then I will be a criminal…

    For anyone who thinks who you voted for is supposed to represent you, think again, they all run for election now for one thing… $$$. The few politicians with a spine, are relegated to the side lines by corporate interests.

  113. Tyler Pubben says:

    Calm down people.
    I find it hilarious that every time I come across an article on a topic such as this almost every person who responds is argumentative and belligerent. The truth of the matter is that piracy is at an all-time high and we need to find a better way to stop it or premium content will eventually become too costly to produce given reducing numbers of customers who actually buy it.

    I love the idea of free music, commercial free television shows and the ability to use this media wherever and whenever I want. However as a businessman I have to look at the problem from a more pragmatic perspective. DRM may not be a perfect solution to our problem but it is one of the only solutions we have. For people to complain that they may not be able to play their music 20 or 30 years down the road because of it is absurd. If that were the case then I should be up in arms about my old cassette collection and VHS tapes. More recently I should be sueing Sony for my having to upgrade all my DVDs to blu-ray if I want to have the best quality images I can get. Hell, I should take Microsoft to task because I can’t play all my Xbox games on my 360 now that my old Xbox has died.

    DRM is a technology that will likely evolve or be replaced just like every other technology we use every day. Our parents (and likely even some of us) were able to afford the music they wanted, we can too. Unfortunately our society is so willing to spend $500 dollars on a new iPhone yet we are too cheap to buy the music we put on that device. Here’s an idea, if you can only afford one or the other, buy the music, get a cheaper MP3 player, take the phone that is free on a 1 or two year plan and suck it up. Eat in every day of the week and you can buy a new CD, drink 4 less beers the next time you hit the pub and hit up iTunes for 20 more songs.

    I don’t for one second believe that anyone can listen to, or even enjoy, half the songs they have on their iPods. I know I don’t.

    Yes this bit of legislation is protecting the corporations, but without that protection then they loose money and we loose sources of entertainment. Either that or how about you go to work for the next year and put in a solid effort without being paid for it. There are laws in place to ensure we get paid for our labour, there also have to be laws in place to ensure we pay for our goods, services and media. Believe it or not you can survive without new music or movies. Humanity has done it for millions of years.

  114. Not above…
    I am not above acts of violence that would stop this ‘agreement’ of the wealthy elite. I don’t have much to live for as is and martyrdom for the greater good of the world’s free people would make my life at least meaningful.

  115. Andrei Mincov says:

    Too much socialism
    It must be realized that if ACTA gets approval in the U.S., then the next step could be to subject the continued connectivity of the American Internet to the rest of the world to a condition that the country that wishes to be connected adopt ACTA.

    Technically, this is not such a big deal.

    The more allies the U.S. collects in the process (and it looks like the EU may be quite supportive), the more sense the system will be.

    If ACTA is enacted and Canada refuses to take part in it, let us for one minute imagine the quality of the Internet segments available to Canadians if they have no connectivity with the U.S. segments of the Internet.
    ACTA makes a lot of sense. Without cooperation of ISPs, enforcement is meaningless. It is time we say ENOUGH to taking the use of someone else’s works for free for granted. There is no right to use someone else’s property simply because one feels like it.

    I wholeheartedly agree with Tyler Pubben: there is really no need to store tens of thousands of songs and hundreds of films on your hard drives. Yes, it is very convenient to download newly released movies off the piratebay, but this completely deforms the business model for those who invest their time, money and talent in creation of those works.

    Just like socialism gradually leads to depletion of funds in a country, because there are no incentives to work better (I fail to understand why the example of the Soviet Union has not made it abundantly clear to everybody), worldwide unauthorized use of works of art under the guise of a broad “public benefit” exceptions would gradually lead to the demise of creativity that requires money to be released.

    The best example is YouTube, imagine it blocking access to EVERY single video that has been posted there without express consent of copyright owners. How many people would still be using it? Yes, there may be alternative business models, but a business that works under the “supervision” of a racketeer is also a business model of survival. It does not make it any more legitimate. Those artists who care more that their art is disseminated over the Internet for free have legal capacity to do so (yes, it would require that they do not assign their rights to producers). Shielding of ISPs without anything in return is nothing but authorization of racketeering.

    ISPs are the cornerstone of the framework of the Internet. Without them, there is no Internet.

    Instead of promoting a system where efficient enforcement of IPR is impossible, we must work on the wording to make sure that freedom of speech (provided that the speech does not infringe someone else’s IPR) is not compromised under the guise of protection of IPR.

  116. Paul Forbes says:

    These guys are DRM’ing themselves out of business.
    Bring on the DRM I say – and watch the world lose interest in the DRM protected products…

  117. Andrei Mincov says:

    –> Paul Forbes
    Let the creators decide how to disseminate their works. If they feel the model is not working because people are not buying their stuff, it will be THEIR decision to change it. Racketeering creators by stealing their works and then claiming “You know what, your outdated model of trying to make a living must be changed” is just immoral, illegal, robinhoodian and nonviable in the long run.

  118. Andrei Mincov says:

    –> Michael Geist
    Even though I completely disagree with your assessment of the potential consequences if ACTA is enacted, I would like to thank you for your efforts in lifting the veil of secrecy from the document. I must agree that the secrecy around the document takes away from its value somewhat. I hope they learn the lesson and come up with a more meaningful press release, if not with the disclosure of the draft. And then I hope it is enacted, including in Canada.

  119. Times Change 1
    “The truth of the matter is that piracy is at an all-time high and we need to find a better way to stop it or premium content will eventually become too costly to produce given reducing numbers of customers who actually buy it.”

    Perhaps “premium content” is in its dying days? We don’t NEED “premium content”, especially with so many people like myself who don’t mind being creative for free. I have found my generation has a preference for fame over riches. If ACTA comes into law and copyright becomes super strict then your material will die…guaranteed. My generation will come along, get fed up with the restrictions, and migrate to fairer artists who don’t sue their customers for every last penny they, their kids, and their grandkids will ever make. Honestly, I think you and your “business” may have more to fear from ACTA than we do.

    “I love the idea of free music, commercial free television shows and the ability to use this media wherever and whenever I want. However as a businessman I have to look at the problem from a more pragmatic perspective.”

    Perhaps your job has been outdated by technology and users who now have the means to create content all by themselves. Whip makers were outdated by technology once the car came along…maybe you’re “whips” are being outdated by users “cars“.

    “DRM is a technology that will likely evolve or be replaced just like every other technology we use every day. Our parents (and likely even some of us) were able to afford the music they wanted, we can too.”

    I can afford it and I do. I have spent about $1600 in the last year and a half on music related products alone (that‘s not including the several hundred dollars worth of movies I bought as well). Then I back it up on my computer/“cheaper” mp3 player. I also have programs that let me easily break the region coding DRM on my legally imported DVDs. What gives you entertainment companies the right to make it so difficult for me to watch the movies I love when it is perfectly legal to do so? I also listened to a downloaded copy of Morning Musume’s single “Mikan” while I went to the store to buy the( $15!!!) CD single. Many of us “pirates” are more than happy to…and often do…buy. Downloading is instant (so we don’t have to wait until we get a chance to go to the store) and allows us to concentrate our money towards music and artists we actually love…plus it opened me up to Japanese music so I am not limited to Britney Spears, Kanye West, etc…none of which I like at all. I have found I’ve made a shift to just waiting and buying the music I love once I found an import store that would sell it to me…I rarely download anything I know I can go pick up in a day or two anymore.

  120. Times Change 2
    “Yes this bit of legislation is protecting the corporations, but without that protection then they loose money and we loose sources of entertainment. Either that or how about you go to work for the next year and put in a solid effort without being paid for it.”

    I am willing to create for free. I have made short films, written stories, and am working on a play because I love to do that sort of thing…not because anybody has paid me.

    “Believe it or not you can survive without new music or movies. Humanity has done it for millions of years.”

    If ACTA comes into being, it looks like we’ll have to…at least until the media giants come crashing down after a mass public boycott. Well…there’s always the entertainment people like me are willing to create free of cost/for donations.

    “It must be realized that if ACTA gets approval in the U.S., then the next step could be to subject the continued connectivity of the American Internet to the rest of the world to a condition that the country that wishes to be connected adopt ACTA.”

    If the US really wants to cut their online businesses off from the rest of the world, especially in today’s economy, I say let them. We’ll see how long that lasts before there is a revolution.

    “there is really no need to store tens of thousands of songs and hundreds of films on your hard drives.”

    Yeah there is:
    1. I paid for it and I am not sharing it with someone who hasn’t
    2. Its easier to travel when you don’t use up your entire allowed weight in an airplane with DVDs
    3. That’s what an mp3 player is for, yes?

    “The best example is YouTube, imagine it blocking access to EVERY single video that has been posted there without express consent of copyright owners. How many people would still be using it?”

    Well the industry has two options:
    1 Jump on the bandwagon and make financial agreements with it, thus making extra money
    2. Police and file DMCA takedown notices on all their videos they can find and sit outside one of the best money making advertising opportunities available ever

    “Let the creators decide how to disseminate their works. If they feel the model is not working because people are not buying their stuff, it will be THEIR decision to change it.”
    The only reason DRM hasn’t killed the industry yet is because enough people can get around it. That is the only reason. I wouldn’t be going through the effort to import foreign region coded DVDs if I couldn’t break that DRM, would I?

  121. Andrei Mincov says:

    –> Ben
    “I am willing to create for free. I have made short films, written stories, and am working on a play because I love to do that sort of thing…not because anybody has paid me.”

    And do you think you would get the same audience as professional artists whose income is generated by their arts? It can be less of an issue if you have another source of income. And no, I do not believe that there is such a thing as telling an artist what should be enough for them. That’s a socialist approach which I despise.

    You obviously do have another source of income, so you are free to decide whether you create your stuff for fame, for money or for both. And no one is forcing you into selling out.

    On the other hand, I am going to buy CDs of my favourite bands, even if I can get music by someone I don’t know for free. It is not just about the cost.

    “We’ll see how long that lasts before there is a revolution. ”

    You mean war, right? If Canada is disconnected from the US internet because it refuses to cooperate to fight P2P piracy, do you think Canada will declare a war against the US? Or do you think there will be revolution in Canada to ensure that Canada’s copyright laws advance from the stone age state they currently are?

    “The only reason DRM hasn’t killed the industry yet is because enough people can get around it”

    I agree that DRM sucks, both in principle and in reality. It was designed to overcome unwillingness of ISPs to cooperate. To me, the failure of DRM was the last straw that led to the development of ACTA. It became obvious that if ISPs are not part of the solution, then there is no solution.

  122. Christopher says:

    I have a severe problem with international agreements making DRM circumvention illegal
    And some people miss a salient point: 90% or more of the ‘illegal copies’ of stuff on the internet is of stuff that should be OUT OF COPYRIGHT and PATENT time now, or they are ‘abandonware’ stuff…. like games that are not sold anymore in any way, shape or form anywhere…. and therefore, downloading them on the internet is the ONLY WAY TO GET THEM!

    I download quite a few older games on a regular basis ‘illegally’…. but I know that the companies in question won’t try to sue me because all I would have to do…. tell the judge “Hey, I tried to find these things online legally, and NO ONE SELLS THEM ANYMORE! Or, no one sells them without a BOATLOAD of DRM ‘protections’ that can damage my computer!”

    Yes, I said it: [B]DRM CAN DAMAGE YOUR COMPUTER![/B] The companies in question here would love for you to not believe that…. but judging from my experiences with SecuROM and StarForce messing up my BRAND NEW Windows 7 installation….. I know it’s true!

  123. Ben
    “The harm from current worldwide IP infringement is much greater than potential dangers of censorship.”

    lmao..I was wondering why there was so many responses on here. I see that industry has sent out their goons once again. Ben, there’s an absence of evidence to prove your point here, even within industry. Do you really think society will allow censorship and control over civil rights to those in the entertainment industries? There are a lot of factors right now that are contributing to the downfall of “some” in the IP industries. IP infringement being the least of your worries, the attitude displayed by industry and yourself should be at the forefront.

    If you are a creator, than I think you need to decode yourself a bit. If we are to give up civil liberties with respect to IP enforcement than we should equally restrict the subjects creators create works on, and while we’re at it, we might as well look for Hilter’s double. Society will not let this type of censorship occur. If you think different, then you should be looking for another career path. It ain’t going to happen especially after historic lessons that society has learned on when you hand control and censorship to a few loose cannons like yourself. Canadian Artists, and creators overwhelmingly disapproved with your point in the copyright consultations. So which of the big four labels are you with?

  124. Considering that the Vice President was known for his entertainment industry connections, why is anyone surprised by this?

  125. Jason >

    That wasn’t me who said that. I strongly believe in having my civil liberties and as a person who creates FOR FREE, I believe in having no censorship whatsoever. I HATE ACTA and will do what I can to prevent its signing into law in Canada.

    “They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.” ~ Benjamin Franklin

    Andrei >

    “And do you think you would get the same audience as professional artists whose income is generated by their arts?”

    Perhaps eventually. Look at Justin Bieber or Belle de Jour. The key to getting in audience is not how good your product is, but your advertising. Online, advertising CAN take off on its own…and if not, you’ve got the world at your finger tips to star advertising your stuff internationally for free. You don’t need millions of dollars to put you movie trailer in the theatres or TV…all you need is youtube, a marketing gimick, and membership at a few forums that would be interested. Even big corporations are taking note on that…that’s all Media Blasters really did when they released “The Machine Girl” and that DVD was a top seller for weeks.

    “On the other hand, I am going to buy CDs of my favourite bands, even if I can get music by someone I don’t know for free. It is not just about the cost.”

    What part of I buy CDs too don’t you understand? I just use the internet to sift through and then put all my money into the artists I like. Avex is one label that knows how music works in this age: they put all their PVs on youtube so people like me can watch them and decide which artists I like that way. They probably make money from the ads on their pages in the process so even if I decide I hate the artist they can get some money for me watching it.

    “You mean war, right? If Canada is disconnected from the US internet because it refuses to cooperate to fight P2P piracy, do you think Canada will declare a war against the US? Or do you think there will be revolution in Canada to ensure that Canada’s copyright laws advance from the stone age state they currently are?”

    No, I don’t mean war…I know Canada won’t go to war over that. I mean’t the online businesses in the US will start demanding access to the rest of the world. You think Google would just stand by as the president cut off China and Canada? Also, that level of online censorship isn’t even possible because people will just go around it.

    If ACTA becomes law, I think there will be a consumer revolt against Hollywood…it has already been happening, but it has been very uncoordinated. People will be pushed to the edge by this legislation and fight back with civil disobedience and boycotts. As I said before, this legislation is probably worse for the industry than consumers. You guys are building your coffin.

    I agree that DRM sucks, both in principle and in reality. It was designed to overcome unwillingness of ISPs to cooperate. To me, the failure of DRM was the last straw that led to the development of ACTA. It became obvious that if ISPs are not part of the solution, then there is no solution.”

    There is no solution except to adapt. Are you industry goons really that incapable of understanding basic market forces? You’ve lost…all the draconian legislation won’t do a thing for you. There are simply too many of us to put in jails and that will refuse to pay any fines.

  126. Correction to Previous Post
    “I agree that DRM sucks, both in principle and in reality. It was designed to overcome unwillingness of ISPs to cooperate. To me, the failure of DRM was the last straw that led to the development of ACTA. It became obvious that if ISPs are not part of the solution, then there is no solution.” ~ Andrei Mincov

    There is no solution except to adapt. Are you industry goons really that incapable of understanding basic market forces? You’ve lost…all the draconian legislation won’t do a thing for you. There are simply too many of us to put in jails and that will refuse to pay any fines.

  127. Andrei Mincov says:

    Revolt against Hollywood
    Sure, there are so many of you who would be happy to revolt against Hollywood and confine themselves to whatever is produced by amateurs worldwide, for free.

    You are effectively suggesting that professional artists become amateurs. Which would in turn rob us of whatever may be created by those who risk to invest their time in developing their talents as their SOLE path of career.

    –> Ben
    “What part of I buy CDs too don’t you understand?”

    If you continue robbing artists of their rights to control the use of their works and to receive what they think if fair, there will be no CDs to buy. Again, forcing artists to give up their rights by violating their rights and calling this “adoption of a new business model” is nothing but racketeering.

    –> Jason:
    I don’t work for any of the entertainment giants. I don’t work for entertainment industry at all. I simply see the value of strong copyright enforcement, and if ISPs are not a part of the solution, then there is no solution to that at all.

    I guess we will just wait and see if the mass of pirates breaks the system of IPR and we gradually degrade as a society in result.

  128. for the lulz says:

    Stop complaining
    Its not the end of the world.

  129. Ben + Andrei
    Sorry Ben, my fault..it was actually Andrei that stated that.

    Andrei -> There’s a huge difference between ISP involvement and an attack on a free society are 2 completely different ideologies. I agree with you with respect to ISP’s being part of the solution, but strongly disagree with you on how that is to be done for a number of reasons. Not withstanding the fact of infringing on the rights of a free society in the name of civil copyright enforcement (which anybody thinks is going to happen is seriously in need of a mental check up), but more over technical protections, and ISP “enforcement” will not work. Anyone who has been following up with respect to the CRTC net neutrality hearings can see the fall back with respect to DPI (which would be used by the ISP’s to enforce these rules), and the fact that most P2P programs now have already nullified this technology. Furthermore with darknet services becoming the norm now, file sharing is starting to become very untraceable. The ISP enforcement debate is already obsolete.

    What has gradually degraded, is the expectation that society owes the creative industry demands on the system in play now, when the creative industries have done nothing, absolutely nothing to follow and understand the market they are currently faced with. There is amble evidence to support this. The fact Andrei that you are talking about “CD’s” in this thread is quite representing of your knowledge in this market. You might as well be talking about 8 tracks. I haven’t seen a “CD” walkman on anyone in close to 10 years!

    I agree with you however that something needs to be done. I think that ISP’s should be licensed and pay into a copyright pool for new industry startups, and funding (since this is the ONLY area right now that is currently degrading), and a focus with respect to media on new advertising models that more suit the expectation of shared social media online. That isn’t being done, and in fact a few months ago Industry reps were on Geists blog bitching about his exposure, and the fact they couldn’t get through to Canadians. If they were to figure out why that is, than most of the problems with respect to what we are seeing right now in IP and especially in media wouldn’t exist. Until they put this in place, the argument for strong copyright “enforcement” with respect to the internet user doesn’t hold any weight. There is no evidence to prove the argument nor to support any changes within copyright law as far as I’m concerned.

    A lot of the idiots running things over in the entertainment industry, don’t understand the marketplace as it exists today. No law can change the current problem, even if we went for stronger IP enforcement laws. But don’t take my word for it:

    http://www.apcomms.org.uk/uploads/apComms_Final_Report.pdf

    BTW I am a part of the entertainment industry, representing talent who actually have brains!

  130. Andrei Mincov says:

    –> Jason
    Thanks for the report, I’ll have a look at it. Seems to be exciting reading…

    When I say CDs, I refer to an album, i.e. a collection of new songs recorded by an artist.

    Again, I do agree that the act of ripping a purchased cd into mp3s for one’s own personal use should be decriminalized. But it is not going to happen unless there is some reasonable enforcement of what happens to those mp3s on the net.

    To me, ISPs persistent refusal to cooperate is akin to regulating traffic without any assistance from city authorities or road police. Yes, you can of course go to court every time, but you can’t get any evidence and you can’t really enforce anything in a meaningful manner.

    The Internet would have evolved much more organically, if the ISPs took the side of IPR owners instead of pirates.

    The current problem is that ISPs are still taking every possible step (including bringing in all sorts of civil liberty groups) to make sure that things stay the way they used to be.

    If major players in the equation refuse to cooperate then any attempt to legislate them into cooperation would have its disadvantages. The regulation would be either overly broad or unpermissively narrow.

    However, it is not a reason to just let things ruin the current system by making a reference to inability to provide a perfect solution. There are no perfect solutions. The question is, is an imperfect solution better than the current mess. I would say, it is.

    PS to no one in particular: coming from a country that, until it collapsed, used to be socialist (which was exactly why it had collapsed), I am really stunned by how many people HONESTLY believe that they will have better luck building a socialist utopia in place of what used to be strong market economies.

  131. Holmes Wilson (FSF) says:

    Even using the term “intellectual property” confuses the issue and concedes massive territory to the other side.

    The term refers to totally separate areas of law and policy (e.g. patents and copyright) that work in different ways and exist for different reasons. Using the term just spreads confusion. If we’re talking about copyright, let’s say “copyright”.

    Even worse, it encourages people (even those of us who should know better) to think of copyrights or patents as physical property, which biases the discussion in favor of the forces we’re trying to fight.

    If copyright is a kind of property (which it isn’t) than Hollwood et al. are trying to protect their property, which sounds reasonable.

    If copyright is one of many public policy options to support science and art (which it is) then these companies are pushing for a stupid public policy that harms the public and does nothing to support the arts, as part of a plan to enrich themselves (one which probably won’t even work).

    This is *definitely* a case where how we talk about it changes how the broader public sees it.

  132. -> Andrei
    “When I say CDs, I refer to an album, i.e. a collection of new songs recorded by an artist.”

    The market is now a singles market, not an album market.

    “Again, I do agree that the act of ripping a purchased cd into mp3s for one’s own personal use should be decriminalized. But it is not going to happen unless there is some reasonable enforcement of what happens to those mp3s on the net.”

    The first point on this subject is the fact that DRM was overwhelmingly rejected by the market, followed up by Sony installing “root kits” on their CD’s which had a direct impact on not just privacy, but also with respect to the operations of the systems it installed itself on. Sony was sued on that.

    As some with a technical background, I can tell you that no matter what “software” or “hardware” is installed to protect an MP3 from finding it’s way online, someone will find the back door and put it online anyway. It hasn’t worked over the past 10 years. It’s a dead issue, and no longer realistic to the discussion. The market made their choice on that. Moving forward with TPM’s or DRM gives the creators a false scene of security. These protection measures are meant as a deterrence, but can not be enforced in the digital realm, unless we start installing camera’s in every bedroom, living room, and basement in Canada.

    The problem most are unwilling to accept is basically a virtual stalemate. Anything industry does to try and protect content, will eventually be exploited online. What we need to do is move away from trying to protect and control an environment that is not controllable, and look at monetizing IP rather than enforcing it with respect to the general population and consumer.

    I agree with you that there is not perfect solution, however the solutions that industry presents are purely policy driven towards a socialist agenda and that is the reason why it will fail. In order to enforce policies such as ACTA we would be looking at turning a medium into a tightly controlled environment with severe penalties that do not fit the crime, nor are acceptable within free market principles, nor a free society. It would allow a selected few to have total control over content displayed online, the marketplace, consumer choices, and that’s not good for society in general nor creators. This has been overwhelmingly rejected here in Canada by both Industry and Creators themselves.

    Therefore the choices are very simple and are as follows:

    1) Spend insane amounts of money installing DPI (that is already obsolete) to enforce IP laws online (that can not be enforced practically), and piss off your income base instigating product revolt on bad public relations, and costing several politicians their jobs.

    or

    2) Give up some of the control on IP, monetize it in a way that’s practical and will work, engage the marketplace aggressively, and above all be consumer friendly rather than pissing them off (ever chance you get) by taking away things they want to do with purchased media which includes sharing it with friends, family, and on social media.

    File sharing will always exist, but if you use it and understand it, you can develop marketing techniques to benefit from it. If you fight it, then you lose out on a large portion of potential income, and you end up not surviving for long within the marketplace.

    There will be resistance from the ISP’s on the issue of monetization. Currently our ISP’s are charging insane rates while consumers get basically nothing with respect to service and speed. Greed is ever present with respect to all corporate players in this debate. That’s why the public needs to be engaged in this, and are in a big way in Canada. As it always will be in this debate, it will be up to consumers where are public policy on copyright ends up, not politicians, and most certainly not those who are currently not engaged in the marketplace.

  133. Look folks…
    I think it’s time we think about something other than music piracy when it comes to DRM. What about books? What happens when all information is locked up with DRM by the corporations? I don’t know, but I’m very concerned about a “pay per play” model within the libraries of the future. I figure, some day relatively soon, nearly any publication; whether it be a magazine, journal, or book; will be digital, as this will cut costs for the publisher drastically. Awful hard to write a paper when it’s illegal to quote anything without paying for it (which as I understand it, is what happens when you take away fair dealing/fair use rights). That’s my ultimate concern with it all.

  134. theravenhides says:

    welcome to the new world
    who cares if we can’t download music. who cares if we can’t pirate anymore. this is bigger than all of that. we are talking Worldwide censorship ability. In my opinion this is a direct shot to our freedom of speech. I am displeased in Obama and outraged and this subject. I do not personally understand why obama a self proclaimed peoples president would take part in such discussions, and especially take part in them knowing full well what this would mean for the entire world let alone america and not make this more open.
    These things happening today are unbelievable. To think that a bill would even be thought about or discussed of criminalizing organic and small farms because they “endanger” the safety and health of america (HR875 introduced by Rosa DeLauro). To think countries would get together and discuss the possible silencing of our global information sharing database. This is what has brought the world into our new era. The internet is a gift. and they want to take it away from us. I myself am looking for anyway to get involved with this topic. They can already hear anything we say on phones and now they will be able to silence us where they have never been able to

  135. DISINFODESTROYER says:

    Researcher
    This is just wonderful. Things like this wouldn’t happen if people payed attention to whats going on around them. And this isn’t supposed to be a democracy, its supposed to be a constitutional republic with rights that CAN NOT be taken.

  136. s
    Non compliance is the only way. I’m tired of manditory this and copyright that.

  137. Criminal Lawyer Vancouver says:

    Criminal Lawyer Vancouver
    Great!!!

    Criminal Lawyer Vancouver

  138. i hope no one is stupid enough to buy anything from some idiot that says you have to pay royalties to tape a tv show. you know why that isn’t a crime? because it went to the courts, and they said it’s fair use. that’s why the vcr didn’t have to have drm-like technology in it.

    i wish everyone could sell copies of their work for a living. a janitor wouldn’t have to go into work, he could just record cleaning toilets and then charge for each day the tape was played. then if anyone else used his “trademark” of using a particular back-and-forth motion with the mop he could sue for infringement. now he’s selling copies and living off lawyers. there’s no 10% in being a shill. you’re not living off your work, you’re the scum of the earth. go kill yourself, jacob. i don’t want your crappy “art.”

  139. According to the study, the most important tool for small businesses to succeed in 2010 is search engine marketing, while email marketing, public relations and social media cited as crucial for success.
    23.8% of all small businesses reported that search engine marketing was the tool most needed for their business to succeed in 2010.

    onlineuniversalwork

  140. ACTA on Topix
    Google CNN and ACTA and you will get nothing,the only comments are mostly ME!

    Under Trollicus, Cackus, Angst smarmy etc..

    It’s really sad that the media has so OBVIOUSLY censored news about ACTA. One of the few mainstream media reports on ACTA is a Pro-ACTA propaganda piece on 60 minutes that might as well be a paid advertisement!

  141. online marketimg
    Affiliate Marketing is a performance based sales technique used by companies to expand their reach into the internet at low costs. This commission based program allows affiliate marketers to place ads on their websites or other advertising efforts such as email distribution in exchange for payment of a small commission when a sale results.

    http://www.onlineuniversalwork.com

  142. kiramatalishah says:

    kiramatalishah.seo@gmail.com
    How To Make money with affiliate programs Today. Affiliate marketing is the easier and probably the most effective method to make money from the internet. It is basically, a kind of selling technique where potential buyers from your website are directed to the websites of sellers. For every click, the website owner gets a small commission.
    http://www.onlineuniversalwork.com

  143. royalty free music
    maybe you need royalty free music ? check out this website
    http://www.massivetracks.net/royalty-free-music.htm

    greets fluxx

  144. Online Degree Guide
    Now it’s time for personal contact. The Online Degree Guide gives you contact information for the most-requested online universities and schools. Call them up. Email them. Speak to an admissions counselor to dig deeper, and see if earning your degree online through them will meet your financial, time, and career advancement requirements. …..

    Study while you work

  145. fools and luddiites in the information revolution
    Legal restrictions, that restrict access to information resources and information refinement/review tools increased economic inefficiency for the short term profit of those who control access to information until the restricted access makes the information forgotten and as result worthless.

    Information as a resources unlike physical resources, it does increase in value when access is restricted. Restricted information becomes forgotten information. It is constant refinement and review that provides information long term value as a resource.

  146. Oportunidade única, vendo 2 licenças do tvhd no pc por R$20,00 cada,
    eu adquirir um pacote de canais do TVHD no PC no http://www.tvhd.com.br e recebi 4 licenças, eu utilizo somente uma licenças outra eu já vente para meu primo e estou vendendo as outras 2 quem tiver interesse favor entrar em contato edu_new@terra.com.br
    cada licença tem duração de 2 anos

  147. Costs issue
    I have no problem buying any of the music, DVDs or movie tickets but what I do have issue with is the cost. How is 50 bucks reasonable for a DVD of the first season of Castle? When these shows are already paid for by the advertiser, frankly this is the reason people copy stuff. They say the increase the cost because they are being ripped off by copiers. Hum, they might need to think about this…

  148. This treaty is not only inefficient, but ineffective, and is likely to cause more harm than good.
    If you agree with the above statement, visit
    http://www.anti-acta.com
    Or visit our IRC
    http://n0v4.com/irc.web.php?channel=antiactaplanning
    We are trying to stop this treaty as well.

  149. O Tv Digital no PC consiste em transformar seu computador ou notebook numa completa central de entretenimento sem nenhuma burocracia ou complicação, basta que o seu computador tenha uma conexão com a internet com a velocidade mínima de 100kbps, não e necessário placa de tv ou vídeo 3D nem cabos os antenas.
    Com o Tv Digital no PC você terá 452 canais á sua inteira disposição 24horas
    http://www.tvdigitalnopc.com.br

  150. A tecnologia da Tv Digital via internet chegou para lhe proporcionar assistir canais ao vivo em seu computador.
    452 canais de Tv Digital transmitidos 24h por dia Ao Vivo, sem taxas de assinatura ou mensalidades
    http://www.tvdigitalnopc.com.br

  151. http://www.uggsoutletboots.com
    Well said. I never thought I would agree with this opinion, but I’m starting to view things from a different view. I have to research more on this as it seems very interesting. One thing I don’t understand

    though is how everything is related together.

  152. Mens hats
    This is a really good read for me. Must agree that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw. Thanks for posting this informative article.
    http://www.suitsmen.co.uk/accessories/mens-hats/

  153. Mens hats
    A variety of men’s hats and caps from traditional to contemporary. FREE UK Delivery and returns on all items.

  154. basketball uniforms says:

    basketball uniforms
    UngDungViet :: THI?T K? WEBSITE :: THUONG M?I ÐI?N T? :: thi?t k? web, thi?t k? web giá r?, công ty thi?t k? website, Ðang ký tên mi?n, thuê host, luu tr? website, Thiet ke website, thuong mai dien tu, cong ty thiet ke website, Dang ky ten mien, thue host, hosting, luu tru website, thiet ke web, l?p trình web, lap trinh web, gia công website, gia cong website, dang ký domain, thiet ke logo, thiet ke brochure, thiet ke name card, quang ba web, quang ba thuong hieu, thi?t k? logo, thi?t k? brochure, qu?ng bá web, qu?ng bá website, qu?ng bá thuong hi?u, top 10 google yahoo msn alexa, maketing website, webdesign, e-commerce, web development, e-marketing, vietitpro, vi?t web, web viet, chuyên nghi?p, uy tín, hi?u qu?, sáng t?o, ch?t lu?ng, tr?n gói
    basketball uniforms
    football uniforms

  155. soccer uniforms says:

    soccer uniforms
    dien thoai, linh kien dien thoai, linh kien may tinh
    soccer uniforms
    youth soccer uniforms

  156. gain twitter followers says:

    gain twitter followers
    Twitterner is a leader Twitter Company that will get More Twitter Followers to your profile increasing your traffic and revenues. 100% Real Followers Guaranteed
    gain twitter followers
    twitter marketing

  157. shirley of hollywood says:

    shirley of hollywood
    Hello this is a good write-up. I’m going to mail this to my associates. I stumbled on this while searching on google I’ll be sure to come back. thanks for sharing.

    http://deviousthings.com/index.php?cPath=155

  158. magnetic health care products says:

    magnetic health care products
    I love your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you create this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz reply back as I’m looking to create my own blog and would like to know wheere u got this from. thanks

    http://www.divinehandicrafts.com

  159. Mens hats
    hello the info on this site is just amazing it keeps us coming back time and time again ,personally i met my wife using this site so i couldn’t like it any more i have done my best to promote this blog as i know that others need to read this thing ,thank you for all the effort spent in making this fabulous blog ! OK,cheers.

    http://www.suitsmen.co.uk/accessories/mens-hats/

  160. hire sound engineer says:

    hire sound engineer
    Interesting post. I came across this blog by accident, but it was a good accident. I have now bookmarked your blog for future use. Best wishes.

    http://mymusiccircle.com/

  161. Ενεργειακη επιθεώρηση κτιρίων says:

    Ενεργειακη επιθεώρηση κτιρίων
    Great Blog. I add this Post to my bookmarks.
    http://www.energiakos-epitheoritis.gr/

  162. baby websites says:

    baby websites
    Thank You for sharing your knowledge, Really nice post

    http://www.mybabysite.net/

  163. oakley
    share my site: http://www.shoponcn.com

  164. car finance
    This is just wonderful. Things like this wouldn’t happen if people payed attention to whats going on around them. And this isn’t supposed to be a democracy, its supposed to be a constitutional republic with rights that CAN NOT be taken.
    http://www.carloan4u.co.uk/

  165. Hello
    I think It was a necessary thing that you are going to start,will be beneficial for us also.
    buy p90x

  166. hearing loss says:

    hearing loss treatment
    Nice post, it takes a lot to put those pieces together

    -Stan the hearing loss man
    share my site: http://thehearingfix.com
    or hearing loss

  167. the post
    What a great looking post about hearing loss and it’s range of effects

  168. If you say so
    Here are some interesting links
    hearing loss
    hearing loss
    a href=”http://thehearingfix” rel=”me dofollow”
    a href=”http://thehearingfix” rel=”dofollow”

    My blog

  169. james the tini says:

    This is what they were supposed to look like
    Those links were supposed to look like this
    hearing loss
    hearing loss
    a href=”http://thehearingfix.com” rel=”me dofollow”
    a href=”http://thehearingfix.com” rel=”dofollow”

    My blog

  170. source
    I found good source of steroids,See http://www.steroids.host56.com
    There are many good products with good quality,i checked it personally

    Buy anabolic steroids online, sell roids, want steroids, need steroids, buy clenbuterol,buy deca norma, online anabolic steroids, bulk orders, wholesaler , buy danabol , buy methandienone, buy testosterone, buy eurochem, buy british dragon, shering, buy sustanon, buy tamoxifen zitazonium , buy iran galenika, sell enanthate, sell androlic, sell clenbuterol, sell buy steroids

  171. glasses
    I found good source of steroids,See http://www.shoponcn.com
    There are many good products with good quality,i checked it personally

  172. rewr
    yesterday, my friend bought a yves saint laurent which is so beautiful, i am surprised by the design and style.

  173. store
    you will be able to http://womenonlinestore.com progress much faster in your business.

  174. nice post
    Stan the hearing loss man
    share my site:http://allboxset.com

  175. nice post
    Stan the hearing loss man share my site: http://allboxset.com thank you.

  176. This is the good matter.
    Yeah,I also appreciate their new project plan.Everything should be accepted which will help to keep our environment net and clean.Thanks all who are working in this team.Polluting of water for the waste water leaking is normal affair in 3rd world countries.They should be concern about the harmful affect of waste water.

  177. shhop
    http://www.mbtsale2us.com for save your money.

  178. That’s a good idea~
    http://www.mbt-buy.com

  179. Very good!
    Ecelent Post, Congratulacions!

    sex shop
    sexshop

  180. amorsexshop
    ótimo artigo, gracias

    sexshop | http://www.amorsexshop.com.br

  181. http://www.hayda.net/
    That is very good comment you shared.Thank you so much that for you shared those things with us.Im wishing you to carry on with ur achivments.All the best.

  182. PirateAsia says:

    Yes. May be right ^_^
    In my opinion, the governments should have the appropriate policies about Internet enforcement in order to make worldwide connections secured.
    http://shopbep.net/

  183. Time & Agree
    http://siteit.vn/home/
    The governments maybe need more times to discuss in order to get a common agreement about Internet enforcement.

  184. cam balkon says:

    http://www.megacambalkon.com
    Precious Formals evening gowns are delicate and on the common schedule high-priced pieces of outfits so when you have obtained yours you will critically desire to hold out anything you can to hold treatment of it. there are lots of of how-to’ cheap cocktail dress in circumstance you desire to retain your prom gown in most appropriate type for several years which means you or an extra person can hold satisfaction within your apparel you at first fell in adore with.

  185. cam balkon says:

    http://www.prizmacambalkon.com
    Remember all those science fiction books/TV show and movies that paint a very bleak future for the average person, well here another big push towards making fiction into reality.

  186. web tasarım says:

    http://www.anadoludesign.com
    The governments maybe need more times to discuss in order to get a common agreement about Internet enforcement.

  187. düğün salonu says:

    http://www.bagdatdugunsalonu.com
    Yeah,I also appreciate their new project plan.Everything should be accepted which will help to keep our environment net and clean.Thanks all who are working in this team.Polluting of water for the waste water leaking is normal affair in 3rd world countries.They should be concern about the harmful affect of waste water.

  188. Interesting post and thanks for sharing. Some things in here I have not thought about before.Thanks for making
    dubai seo services
    dubai web design
    dubai web development
    dubai web hosting

  189. http://www.topluchat.com Chat
    http://www.topluchat.com/
    That is very good comment you shared.Thank you so much that for you shared those things with us.Im wishing you to carry on with ur achivments.All the best.

  190. laptop battery dell says:

    http://www.laptopbatterydell.com/
    Pretty good post. I just found your site and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your posts.

  191. http://www.escortbayan.com.tr says:

    escort bayan
    escort bayan

  192. escort bayan says:

    http://www.escorttbayan.com
    escort bayan mecidiyeköy

  193. eescort yaprak says:

    beylikdüzü escort bayan
    http://www.escortyaprak.com

  194. ÅŸiÅŸli escort bayan says:

    ÅŸiÅŸli escort bayan
    http://www.escortsevval.net

  195. thans
    The first priority of the site administrator for your comments right know, thank you. Really very good information-sharing gives you.
    Ä°kinci El EÅŸya Alanlar

  196. thansk
    The first priority of the site administrator for your comments right know, thank you. Really very good information-sharing gives you.
    http://www.mehmetkabatas.com

  197. Promotional Bags & Hats says:

    http://www.chinaamanda.com
    http://www.amandamall.comThe first priority of the site administrator for your comments right know, thank you. Really very good information-sharing gives you.
    Ä°kinci El EÅŸya Alanlar

  198. escort bayan says:
  199. escort bayan says:
  200. weizhili says:

    百度
    [url= http://www.sina.comsina/url

  201. travesti
    htpp://www.travestiguzelleri.com

  202. mecidiyeköy escort bayan says:

    mecidiyeköy escort bayan
    http://www.sexyesma.com

  203. beylikdüzünde günlük kiralık daireler says:

    hii
    beylikdüzünde günlük kiralık daireler evler.

    http://www.beylikduzundegunlukkiralik.com

  204. escort ankara says:

    http://www.escortbayan.com.tr
    escort bayan , escort bayan ankara, escort bayan istanbul, ankara escort, istanbul escort, escort arıyorum

  205. Great, I will bookmark your site and take the feeds also.I’m happy to find numerous useful info here in the post, we need word out more strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing.
    http://www.ndstrade.com/Acekard

  206. Clique Sexshop says:

    https://www.cliquesexshop.com.br
    Very good post, thanks!!!
    blog.cliquesexshop.com.br

  207. Vintage Chanel Jewelry says:

    http://www.jewelrystores.cc/chanel-jewelry-c-42.html
    life-style preferred for any motorsport action. Keep the look good and also clean this year from the sleek silhouet

  208. Purchase Biltricide Online says:

    Good One
    i have read your blog and find that your articles are amazing, i have added this into my bookmark. thanks a lot.

    http://www.buydarvocetonline.net

  209. Buy Darvocet n 100 says:

    http://www.buydarvocetonline.net
    I respect your work , thanks for all the informative articles.

  210. Purchase Biltricide Online says:

    http://www.shopeastwest.com/med/health-wellness/Biltricide/361.html
    what a helpful post this is. Thanks for posting such an informative article. Buy Aldara is a really very effective medice, but people should aslo buy darvocet n100 for pain relief.

  211. http://www.salonyakamoz.com says:

    SALON YAKAMOZ DÜĞÜN DAVET
    THANK YOU ADMÄ°N.

  212. SALON YAKAMOZ says:

    http://www.salonyakamoz.com
    thank you admin…….

  213. Zip Repair says:

    Repair Zip Files
    Very nice blog!

    File repair
    http://www.zip-repair.org

  214. Data Recovery says:

    Data Recovery Software
    data recovery

    love you so much!! Thank you so much.

    http://www.sanmaxi.org

  215. ELÄ°T BMW SERVÄ°SÄ°
    http://www.elitbmwservisi.com
    thanks good site.

  216. best dehumidifier says:

    great post
    WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share..more wait .. … There are definitely loads of details like that to take into consideration. That may be a great level to convey up. I offer the ideas above as general inspiration however clearly there are questions just like the one you deliver up where a very powerful factor will be working in sincere good faith. I don?t know if greatest practices have emerged around issues like that, but I’m sure that your job is clearly identified as a fair game. Each girls and boys feel the affect of only a second’s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.
    http://www.best-dehumidifierreviews.org

  217. Android Tablet says:

    Android Tablet
    http://www.besttabletpc.de/tablet-pc-c-555
    Dies ist ein sehr guter Artikel.Es ist wunderbar, ich bin so gespannt, es zu benutzen!Freuen Sie sich auf Ihre unicode aktualisieren.

  218. sarah
    Kindly turn the Fox news off and think for a moment. It’s the American corporatocracy that has caused this; not Obama or any of the other puppets you had a chance to “elect”, nor is it Canada’s preference for not flooding our country with guns (I can only imagine the mental gymnastics it took to come up with THAT one). So long as your politicians are for sale, and for so long as our politicians allow themselves to be bullied by their counterparts to the south we will see more of this.

    To quote a great man, “it’s called the American dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.”

    http://www.noyasystem.com

  219. Please turn the Fox news off and think for a moment. It’s the American corporatocracy that has caused this; not Obama or any of the other puppets you had a chance to “elect”, nor is it Canada’s preference for not flooding our country with guns (I can only imagine the mental gymnastics it took to come up with THAT one). So long as your politicians are for sale, and for so long as our politicians allow themselves to be bullied by their counterparts to the south we will see more of this.

    To quote a great man, “it’s called the American dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.”

    طراحی سایت

  220. sarah
    It’s the American corporatocracy that has caused this; not Obama or any of the other puppets you had a chance to “elect the mental gymnastics it took to come up with THAT one). So long as your politicians are for sale, and for so long as our politicians allow themselves to be bullied by their counterparts to the south we will see more of this.

    To quote a great man, “it’s called the American dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.”

    [url=http://www.noyasystem.com]طراحی سایت[/url]

  221. Renault can clip says:

    Renault can clip
    So long as your politicians are for sale, and for so long as our politicians allow themselves to be bullied by their counterparts to the south we will see more of this. http://www.carsdiagnostictool.com/

  222. http://www.bellspharmacy.com
    Hey, I had been searching on this topic for a long while but I was not able to find great resources like that. Now I feel very confidence by your tips about that, I think you have choosen a great way to write some info on this topic.

  223. http://www.tutuklu.com says:

    chat
    thank you http://www.tutuklu.net

  224. Escort
    thanks admins. http://www.ilanekle.net

  225. Raffle ticket printing says:

    Raffle ticket printing
    Raffle ticket printing

  226. Eye exam in Collinsville says:

    Eye exam in Collinsville
    Eye exam in Collinsville
    You are an ocean of knowledge, otherwise how is it possible to write and express your opinion on every topic so effortlessly. Bow before you!

  227. Port Douglas apartments says:

    Port Douglas apartments
    I would nor agree or disagree with this article, many times its difficult to jump to conclusions without providing the evidence. I would agree with your point, you made a very compelling argument.

    Port Douglas apartments

  228. Fine Dinnerware says:

    Fine Dinnerware
    Fine Dinnerware
    Excellent post I must say… Simple but yet entertaining and engaging… Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.

  229. buy facebook fans says:

    buy facebook fans
    Fanbullet provides the options to buy facebook fans that too at affordable rates and in the quantity you want. This helps in getting more fans. For more details and offers for Facebook fans visit http://www.fanbullet.com/facebook-fans/.

  230. plumbers sunshine coast says:

    plumbers sunshine coast
    I am glad I found this web site, I could not find any knowledge on this matter prior to. Also operate a site and if you are ever interested in doing some visitor writing for me if possible feel free to let me know, I’m always look for people to check out my web site.

  231. Carpet Cleaning Sydney says:

    Carpet Cleaning Sydney
    Too interesting article, all the information is so beneficial and valuable for us. Presentation of article is attractive, so I will bookmark it for sharing it with my family and with my friends. Thanks for sharing nice and pretty post.

  232. Yakamoz Düğün Salonları
    very good.

  233. Yakamoz Düğün Salonları
    http://www.yakamozdugunsalonlari.com
    very good admin.

  234. http://www.tech4mods.com/
    Thank you for the information that provided.

  235. Debbi Samuel says:

    http://services.oodle.in/view/sgfx-financial-limited/2839226111-mumbai-mh/
    HIii.. I like your article so that I read all of your articles in a day. Please continue and keep on writing excellent posts.

  236. r4
    Thank you for the information that provided.

  237. マジコン販売 says:

    http://coolgamer.net
    This is a great one..nice article, thanks for share with us… I learn a lot with your words.. thank for the post.マジコン販売— マジコン 販売
    マジコン 販売— マジコン販売
    Great job!, good to read and agree with your words.

  238. Carpet cleaning accessories says:

    Carpet cleaning accessories
    All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind. Thanks for sharing the information. Keep updating, looking forward for more posts. Thanks.

    Carpet cleaning accessories

  239. egitim
    Thanks for sharing the information. Keep updating, looking forward for more posts. Thanks.
    http://ingilizce.egitimkursu.net/
    http://egitimkursu.net/

  240. Medical assistant degrees says:

    Medical assistant degrees
    I think the author’s writing is very good, although the point of view a little bit different, but really is a good article, and the author can hope to have time to discuss some problems.
    Medical assistant degrees

  241. ilahi dinle says:
  242. www.gla-ksa.com says:

    http://www.gla-ksa.com
    thank you admin

  243. cool
    I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share.

    buy codeine online

  244. Buy Ritalin Online says:

    Abelee
    I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.
    http://www.mycarepharmacy.com/buy_online/methylphenidal/ritalin

  245. Buy Ritalin Online says:

    Abelee
    You provided a valuable service to the community. Thank you for doing such a great job all these years.
    http://www.mycarepharmacy.com

  246. Buy Generic Drugs says:

    http://www.bigdrugstores.com/
    i have read your blog and find that your articles are amazing, i have added this into my bookmark.

  247. Buy Soma Online says:

    http://www.bigdrugstores.com/soma-generic.html
    I respect your work , good information with good examples. I appreciate your work and expect more post from your end.

  248. comprar camisetas says:

    Me gustaría saber donde puedo encontrar el Essiac o los Ingrediants.También la cantidad correcta de usar.
    Oh, yo realmente envidio la forma en que temas posteriores, como me gustaría poder escribir como el `-;. ~ *

  249. chat
    I visit this first time & it has a very valuable information. & some decent design as well. I would like to appreciate writer’s nice effort. http://www.camchat.gen.tr

  250. reply
    de los gráficos es algo interesante … gracias a cualquier software de edición gráfica que nos permite mejorar nuestras imágenes, crear una salida más hermoso … me trate de usar photoshop y los fuegos artificiales en la edición y la mejora de los gráficos .. es genial .. también hay otro programa de edición gráfica como la editor de xara imagen y muchos más .. tratar otros .. es posible que les guste
    http://www.boutiqueairjordan.com/

  251. Wim Vandersnickt says:

    Cupcakes Maken
    “I have been keeping track of your site for a long time I read these articles, this is an interesting reading I will continue to pay attention to it more Your article is one of the most classical style, when I read once, I have been deeply in love with them, you look forward to more perfect work.
    Cupcakes Maken

  252. Fast Approval Article Directory
    This is my first opportunity to visit ur web site. I hv found some interesting thing and i will apply or developing my blog. Keep updating. ur article will help me to finish my university assignment.

  253. nemrut fm says:

    Nemrut Radyo Nemrut fm dinle
    great work !
    NemrutRadyo dinle

    Guney Fm dinle

  254. nemrut fm says:

    Nemrut Radyo Nemrut fm dinle
    http://www.nemrutradyo.com dinle.. en kaliteli muzikler burda.

  255. ACTA
    We’ve got enough real problems here that it’s not worth wasting attention under the bridge.
    Matteo http://freecarads.com

  256. www.cheapnorthfacejacketssale.co.uk says:

    http://www.cheapnorthfacejacketssale.co.uk
    just as they did with the other elements of the treaty.

  257. Foods that burn fat says:

    Foods that burn fat
    Foods that burn fat
    Most of the visitors are here, so please share your experience which you feel practically from your point of view and make everyone aware about this useful website.

  258. Foods that burn fat says:

    http://learneverything07.wordpress.com/2012/09/27/the-foods-that-help-to-lose-belly-fat/
    Most of the visitors are here, so please share your experience which you feel practically from your point of view and make everyone aware about this useful website.

  259. vietnam reisen says:

    thanks a lot
    After examine a couple of of the weblog posts in your web site now, and I actually like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web site checklist and will be checking again soon. Pls check out my website as effectively and let me know what you think. vietnamreisen.asiatica.com
    Your house is valueble for me. Thanks!…

  260. remind
    We hope you enjoy using blogBunch, and we appreciate that you are taking the time to share your comments with us. http://www.dragonseo.net/

  261. vietnam rundreise says:

    Hello very nice website!! Guy .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your web site and take the feeds also?I am glad to find so many useful information right here in the submit, we’d like work out more techniques in this regard, thank you for sharing. . . .http://vietnamrundreise.asiatica.com/entdecken-sie-unsere-reisen.aspx

  262. Green Coffee Bean Extract says:

    Green Coffee Bean Extract
    Thanks so much and stick with it No doubt you will definitely reach your goals! have a great time!
    http://green-coffee-bean-extract.us/

  263. Tynt
    Your blogging site is rather beneficial. Thank you so much for giving many helpful articles and other content. I’ve bookmark your website site and will be without the need of doubt coming back. http://www.filmturk.net The moment yet again, I appreciate all of your do the trick as well as comeing here to communicate with me.

  264. escort bayan says:

    htttp://www.escortbayaniz.org
    Thanks for writing admin

  265. escort bayan says:

    htttp://www.escortbayaniz.org
    Thanks for writing admin

  266. escort bayan says:

    http://www.elitvipescort.com
    This is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your great post. Also, I have shared your site in my social networks!

    I wish you continued success in a very nice blog
    escort
    escort bayanlar
    escort bayan

  267. http://www.themikewylie.com/ says:

    Michael Wylie
    I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me http://www.themikewylie.com/

  268. http://www.siemens-beyazesyaservisi.com says:

    siemens servis
    Congratulations on a wonderful continue to be a site that had a very nice blog.

  269. Moods Condom says:

    Moods Condom
    Its really scary to know about this.May god bless humanity!

  270. Moods Condom says:

    Moods Condoms
    ts really scary to know about this.May god bless humanity!
    http://www.condompoint.com/12_moods

  271. escort bayan says:

    escort bayan
    Its really scary to know about this.May god bless humanity!
    http://www.vipilanlar.com

  272. düğün salonları says:

    düğün salonları
    http://www.salonselay.com/

    wedding halls istanbul..

  273. Thanks
    Thanks alot article. http://voyagevietnam.asiatica.com/

  274. interior design blog says:

    Home improvement
    home improvement often refers to building projects that alter the structure of an existing home.
    it an affordable alternative to the traditional method of employing an architect.
    Extension drawings can be completed entirely online, with no need for a home survey.
    All of the extension and home alterations will be completed within a week!

    http://www.innotect.co.uk/

  275. Dicey stuff, this.
    Ugh, all of this talk of corporations subverting government and replacing citizens is creepy. How about a nice talk about awnings? Who doesn’t like to sit under one of those? Seriously, when will it ever stop being about the money.

  276. Simone D'Angelo says:

    http://www.sexshoptijuca.com.br – Thank you have a nice comments

  277. Charlotte Wedding Photographer says:

    Charlotte Wedding Photographer
    thanks for sharing this with everyone, I found a really good page with loads of pinworms information here. Just like this page it is full of clear advice.

  278. nothing more
    En collaboration avec le spécialiste artiste double lauréat d’un Grammy Dr Dre, le bar rayé fort particulière ainsi que bruyant apparat sur les Beats Studio -casque beats studio diamantcoloré ont a attiré beaucoup d’amateurs de musique comme disque-jockey. La disposition pliable et léger rend le voyage plus facile. Vous seront étonnés à l’accordage fantastique rencontresamsung mobile accessoiresfournir à chacun.SMS SYNC by 50o jouer solde de la carte mettant en évidence le sérieux et l’exécutif ne fait pas exception à la règle. Sur de la musique dite urbaine, le Comité exécutif est souverain. http://www.celikkonstruksiyonfiyatlari.com

  279. Elektrik Tasarrufu says:

    Elektrik tasarrufu
    http://elektriktasarrufu.net

    elektrik tasarrufu için

  280. Yaz Okulu 2014
    http://aquakamp.com

  281. IPL treatment sydney
    Hi ,

    Great article for information point of view .

    IPL treatment sydney

  282. sizegenetics says:

    does sizegenetics work
    This can be among the ideal posts that I’ve ever seen; you might contain some extra ideas inside the similar theme. I’m nonetheless waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side inside your subsequent post.sizegenetics discount

  283. x4 labs discount
    This post provides the light in which we can observe the reality. That is very nice one and provides in-depth information.https://sites.google.com/site/penometgaiters/x4-labs-discount-150-off-promo-code-x4-labs-reviews