Text: Small Text  Normal Text  Large Text  Larger Text
  • Blog
  • 61 Reforms to C-61, Day 38: TPMs - No DRM Regulatory Authority

Blog Archive

PrevPrevMay 2012NextNext
SMTWTFS
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

61 Reforms to C-61, Day 38: TPMs - No DRM Regulatory Authority

PDF  | Print |  E-mail
Wednesday August 13, 2008
One of the ongoing concerns with anti-circumvention provisions is the prospect that the legal rules create incentives to use - and possibly misuse - DRM.  France, which many people hold up as an example of a country that prioritizes copyright and creator protection, has many of the same concerns about DRM misuse and the lack of interoperability.  Its copyright law establishes a DRM authority which is charged with ensuring interoperability. The authority is an independent administrative body focused on DRM.  It submits an annual report to the government and may appear before parliamentary committees on future copyright law reforms.  The creation of a specific body to address these issues is an acknowledgement of the need for regular review of concerns arising from the use of DRM supported by anti-circumvention legislation.  Bill C-61 contains no such acknowledgement or awareness of the prospect of unintended consequences from this legislation.
Comments (8)add comment

Crockett said:

Unintentional?
This legislation is so full of "unintended" roadblocks and loopholes that one might think it was intentionally made bad so it would not pass. I am a life long conservative supporter but if they make this a matter of confidence in the commons then I will never vote for them again. I know many people who will not either.
August 13, 2008

a guest said:

...
excellent point, how can they give legal support to digital locks with no oversight?
August 13, 2008

61 ways to KILL BILL said:

61 ways to KILL BILL
HEY I GOT THE WAY:

61 ways TO FRAKING KILL THE BILL:
ONE: NEVER VOTE for a politician that supports this.
TWO: NEVER VOTE FOR PARTIES that SUPPORT this.

continue:
August 14, 2008

SONY DRM said:

SONY DRM
SEE TPM = DRM
what did i tell you all, michael argues no it isn't yet he uses that DRM ,

REMEMBER SONY PEOPLE.....
August 14, 2008

Trails said:

Leads to a deeper point
It's a good point but leads me to a question pertaining to a more overarching point: are there any controls on DRM in the legislation?

Penalties for compromising a user's computer, la Sony rootkit debacle?
Boundaries of what DRM can and cannot do to a user's computer?

In short, what protections are there for my property (computer, devices, etc...) in the legislation, or is DRM given free reign.
August 14, 2008

Caleb Buxton said:

Analogies
I am a programmer and designer. When I think of the "interface" that DRM affords end-users in knowing what they can and cannot do, it feels sort of like a self-enforcing unreadable contract.

If I buy a DVD with DRM, is it up to me to inform myself of what I can and cannot do with it? If so: who can I take to "read" my DRM to? I can take a contract to a lawyer, but I know my lawyer can't read code like me. Are we going to create an "innovative market place" by creating a new profession for DRM interpretation?

Is it wrong to suggest that the anti-circumvention provision creates new federal-level contract law whose artifacts that represent the contract are only able to be fully read by the creator (of the DRM) ?
August 14, 2008

Igor Mackenzie said:

...
So, what are people doing besides discussing how terribly WRONG bill c-61 is?

Where's the action? On September 15th, when debate on the bill starts again, what do we plan to do to stop it? Nothing?
August 14, 2008

Gregg said:

...
I hate to admit, there is a positive side to this... no DRM regulatory authority = no dedicated enforcement.

Ask any cop if he feels like adding a bunch (as in tens to hundreds of thousands of people per city) of MP3 downloaders to his "bad guy" workload.

The more bad stuff you point out Professor, the more and more obvious that if it passes as-is, it will be completely unenforceable.
August 15, 2008

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
Tags:
, , , , , , , ,
Share: Slashdot, Digg, Del.icio.us, Newsfeeder, Reddit, StumbleUpon, TwitterEmailPrintPDF
Related Items: