Text: Small Text  Normal Text  Large Text  Larger Text

Canadian DMCA: C-61

Why Copyright? Canadian Voices on Copyright Law

Canadian DMCA: 61 Reforms to C-61

Canadian DMCA: What You Need to Know

Canadian DMCA: Voices

Posts On Hot Issues

Blog Archive

PrevPrevJuly 2009NextNext
SMTWTFS
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031

Canada Border Services Opening Lawyer's Mail

PDF  | Print |  E-mail
Sunday January 04, 2009
Cyndee Todgham Cherniak reports that Canada Border Services opened mail addressed to her office at Lang Michener, raising signficant privacy and client confidentiality concerns.
Comments (5)add comment

Anon said:

Constitution-free zones
Borders/customs are "constitution-free zones", only selected laws apply, and you are essentially at the mercy of the system.
January 05, 2009

Vincent Clement said:

Significant? Hardly
Playing the part of the bogeyman today, Michael? I expect much better from you. Just a lot of "what if", "may" and "might". Ms. Todgham Cherniak seems to believe that because she is "a customs lawyer at a prominent Canadian law firm" that she should not be subject to random searches by CBSA. If so, then I'll be addressing all my international purchases to her attention.
January 05, 2009

Jennifer Jilks said:

we are vulnerable
Ms. Cherniak's penultimate paragraph contains a dangerous suggestion. Many US & Canadian government agencies search, flag and/or read e-mail. hackers have no problem getting into e-mail, either.

If clients are using work LANs (i.e., at work) to send messages, they are highly vulnerable. Employers have the right to search messages sent from their systems.

This is not wise advice! Clients are highly vulnerable no matter what they are doing. Blame 9/11 and Homeland Security who have made rules and regs that we must follow, or face the consequences in terms of cross-border transportation and trade.
January 05, 2009

Bytowner said:

Her point?
It might be that if they feel free to do this to her on-the-job mail without fear of legal consequences, what of the rights of the rest of us? What of our mail?

What of your own mail?
January 05, 2009

Marnie Tunay said:

Fakirs Canada
to Signicant? Hardly re your comments: " Ms. Todgham Cherniak seems to believe that because she is "a customs lawyer at a prominent Canadian law firm" that she should not be subject to random searches by CBSA. If so, then I'll be addressing all my international purchases to her attention."

Why would you want to do that, Hardly? Do you have international purchses you would like to hide from customs?

Re: the rest of your comments, you're rude, Hardly, but you're right. Cherniak's real agenda can only be the promotion of her firm, in my opinion. Only diplomats are immune from searches at customs - and I think that they shouldn't be immune, either.
Marnie Tunay
http://fakirscanada.spaces.live.com/default.aspx

January 08, 2009

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
Tags:
,
Share: Slashdot, Digg, Del.icio.us, Newsfeeder, Reddit, StumbleUpon, TwitterEmailPrintPDF
Related Items: