Text: Small Text  Normal Text  Large Text  Larger Text
  • Blog
  • Australian Parliamentary Committee Warns Against ACTA Ratification (For Now)

Blog Archive

PrevPrevApril 2014NextNext
SMTWTFS
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930

Australian Parliamentary Committee Warns Against ACTA Ratification (For Now)

PDF  | Print |  E-mail
Tuesday June 26, 2012
Australia should be added to the growing list of countries that are either rejecting the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement or expressing serious doubts about it. The Australian Joint Standing Committee on Treaties, which conducted an extensive review of ACTA, has just released its report and it is cautioning against ratification for now, noting that "there appears a very real possibility that ACTA will not be ratified by sufficient countries in order to come into existence." The committee found many shortcomings with the treaty.  For example, on secrecy and the lack of transparency:

The most troubling aspect throughout the development of ACTA has been the opaque nature of the process. Whilst DFAT has stated that a certain level of confidentiality is required for trade negotiations, and while there is ground to enable a certain degree of secrecy where complex issues warrant negotiations in confidence, there is no valid rationale for the level of secrecy that DFAT has maintained for what is essentially a copyright treaty.


The report identifies a myriad of substantive question marks on the substance of ACTA and a serious absence of analysis or justifications for the agreement.  In light of its many problems, it recommends holding off ratification for now:

It is prudent, therefore, that ACTA not be ratified by Australia until this Committee has received and considered the assessment of the economic and social benefits and costs of the Agreement, the Australian Government has issued the notice of clarification in relation to the terms of the treaty as recommended in this report and the ALRC has reported on its inquiry into Copyright and the Digital Economy. In considering its recommendation to ratify ACTA, a future Joint Standing Committee on Treaties should have regard to events related to ACTA in other relevant jurisdictions, including the EU and the US.

The ALRC report is not scheduled to be released until late 2013. Moreover, the recommendation to re-examine ACTA at a later date and have regard for developments in Europe and the U.S. suggest that defeat in Europe could influence the decision whether to ratify in Australia.
Comments (3)add comment

Crockett said:

To salesman: "I'll just sign that lease kind sir, no need to show the rate, whatever you think is fair."
Now we should focus our attention on the TPP, they are trying the same old crap all over again and this time Canada has the excuse of 'having' to agree to already set terms.

June 27, 2012

pat donovan said:

illegal, immoral, fattening

Not only rejected, but under court review.

Like harper, passing illegal laws will be backed by merchantile monpolies for the trolls and other
hacks.

I'm waiting for the per-emtive lawsuits.. on terrorist, copyright and slander laws for anyone who opposes the various treaties being smuggled globally.

packrat
June 27, 2012

Byte said:

Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement
The downfall of ACTA will only benefit Europe. USTR Ron Kirk didn't have all MPAA/RIAA's eggs in one basket, the other is the TPP.

TPP was a backup plan and only affects largely undemocratic (in the sense of proportional / equal representation a.k.a. based on popular vote) countries. Look at Canada: the
June 28, 2012

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
Tags:
,
Share: Slashdot, Digg, Del.icio.us, Newsfeeder, Reddit, StumbleUpon, TwitterEmailPrintPDF
Related Items: