Latest Posts

CPCC Goes For Broke, Part One

A remarkable week in music that started with the Steve Jobs call to drop DRM, followed by speculation that EMI will drop DRM, concluded with another critically important development – the Canadian Private Copying Collective, which administers the private copying levy, has asked the Copyright Board to increase the levy on blank CDs and add levies to electronic media cards (storage media) such as SD cards as well as digital audio players such as the Apple iPod.  There is much to consider here, which I will divide between the specific issues raised by the tariff application and the bigger story that is at work.

On the specific tariff application, I think the CPCC is going to have a tough time convincing the Copyright Board (and almost certainly the federal court) that the levy increases and extensions to other media are warranted.  The blank CD increase represents an astonishing request as the CPCC is now openly asking that more than half of the retail price of blank CDs to be comprised of levy costs.  A backgrounder on the CPCC notes that blank CDs cost about 50 cents and that the levy currently comprises 21 cents of that cost.  That is an enormous cost – 42 percent – and the collective wants to increase that by an additional 28 percent.  This is a staggering market distortion that will obviously face very stiff opposition.

The proposal to extend the levy to storage media and Apple iPods also face an uphill climb. The storage media usage data simply does not come close to supporting a levy.  The CPCC's FAQ says that its surveys suggest that 25 percent of content copied onto these cards is music and that 20 percent of people say that the last time they copied onto an electronic memory card, the content was music.   Put another way, 75 percent of content copied onto these cards is not music and 80 percent of people say that the content they last copied onto these cards was not music.  These results are obvious to anyone who owns a digital camera, but apparently not to the CPCC.  While the Copyright Board's definition of ordinary use opens the door to considering storage media, this represents bad, market-distorting policy that (if approved) would force the 80 percent of non-music copiers to subsidize the 20 percent of music copiers.

The attempt to extend the levy to Apple iPods is similarly flawed.  

Read more ›

February 11, 2007 14 comments News

The Future of the Canadian Music Industry

Canadian Heritage has just released a new report [PDF version] on the future of the Canadian music industry that should be required reading for those engaged in music and copyright issues.  Written by Shelley Stein-Sacks, the former head of the government's Music Entrepreneurship Program, the report is remarkable for several […]

Read more ›

February 9, 2007 13 comments News

Oda’s Limo Usage

Liberal MP Michael Savage provides the House of Commons with a minute-by-minute of Bev Oda's limo usage at last year's Juno awards.

Read more ›

February 9, 2007 1 comment News

EMI To Drop DRM?

While the coverage of the Steve Jobs call to drop DRM has focused on somewhat predictable opposition from Warner and the IFPI, the Wall Street Journal and Forbes are reporting this evening that one of the four majors may be ready to drop DRM.  EMI, the world's third largest music […]

Read more ›

February 8, 2007 2 comments News

Bernier Questioned on Net Neutrality

The Bloc picked up on the Bernier-net neutrality coverage, raising the issue with the Minister during question period.  Adopting a method reminiscent of CRIA's mistaking polls for policy, Bernier responded by arguing that polling data suggests that the public supports its position on telecommunications deregulation.

Read more ›

February 8, 2007 1 comment News