Earlier this week, I appeared before the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs as part of its study of Bill C-22, the government’s lawful access bill, joining Leah West and Aaron Shull on the opening panel. I last testified on the bill in May before the House public safety committee, and the amendments adopted in June meant this opening statement started from a different place: the bill is better than when it was first introduced, but more is needed. With only four minutes, I focused on three fixes. Mandatory metadata retention remains constitutionally vulnerable with little evidence of its necessity and should be removed from the bill or, failing that, capped at 30 days. On encryption, the amended definition of systemic vulnerability excludes risks that relate only to people subject to a warrant, which leaves room to order providers to build access capabilities into their systems; the exclusion should be removed and the bill should state directly that no regulation or order may require a provider to weaken encryption. The subscriber information production order relies on the lowest threshold in Canadian criminal law and applies to anyone who provides services to the public, which Justice officials confirmed could include a daycare, and it should be limited to telecommunications service providers and require reasonable grounds to believe. Several senators returned to metadata retention and the 30-day cap in the questions that followed. A video of the opening statement is embedded below, followed by the text.
Archive for November 19th, 2026

Law Bytes
Episode 283: Sabine Witting on Why the French Constitutional Council Struck Down France's Under-15 Social Media Ban
byMichael Geist

November 16, 2026
Michael Geist
November 9, 2026
Michael Geist
November 2, 2026
Michael Geist
October 26, 2026
Michael Geist
October 19, 2026
Michael Geist
Search Results placeholder
Michael Geist on Substack
Recent Posts
Three Fixes for Lawful Access: Making the Case for Amending Bill C-22 at the Senate National Security Committee
Jewish Students Are Telling the Same Story Everywhere But Only Canada Refuses To Listen
What Happened to Competition? Why Sovereignty Is the Wrong Answer to Quebecor’s Bid for Telus
The Law Bytes Podcast, Episode 283: Sabine Witting on Why the French Constitutional Council Struck Down France’s Under-15 Social Media Ban
Back-of-the-Napkin Cultural Policy: The Government’s $600 Million Streaming Plan Copies the CRTC Decision It Killed at More Than Double the Cost

