Earlier this week, I appeared before the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs as part of its study of Bill C-22, the government’s lawful access bill, joining Leah West and Aaron Shull on the opening panel. I last testified on the bill in May before the House public safety committee, and the amendments adopted in June meant this opening statement started from a different place: the bill is better than when it was first introduced, but more is needed. With only four minutes, I focused on three fixes. Mandatory metadata retention remains constitutionally vulnerable with little evidence of its necessity and should be removed from the bill or, failing that, capped at 30 days. On encryption, the amended definition of systemic vulnerability excludes risks that relate only to people subject to a warrant, which leaves room to order providers to build access capabilities into their systems; the exclusion should be removed and the bill should state directly that no regulation or order may require a provider to weaken encryption. The subscriber information production order relies on the lowest threshold in Canadian criminal law and applies to anyone who provides services to the public, which Justice officials confirmed could include a daycare, and it should be limited to telecommunications service providers and require reasonable grounds to believe. Several senators returned to metadata retention and the 30-day cap in the questions that followed. A video of the opening statement is embedded below, followed by the text.
Latest Posts
Jewish Students Are Telling the Same Story Everywhere But Only Canada Refuses To Listen
The stories shock as much for their frequency as their cruelty. A Jewish secondary school student reports that a classmate said he wanted to build a gas chamber and chain up Jews. Another describes classmates and teaching assistants making Holocaust jokes. Yet another was told “welcome to your gas chamber” by someone who noticed their Star of David in a campus bathroom where people were vaping.
My Globe and Mail op-ed notes that these three incidents and hundreds more like them paint a picture of antisemitism in education systems at levels not seen in decades. The secondary school student report appears in a recent British review, which found that three in five Jewish pupils between the ages of 16 and 19 had experienced or witnessed antisemitism and that about half of incidents go unreported. The student reporting Holocaust jokes is taken from a task force study at the University of California, Los Angeles, and the “welcome to your gas chamber” incident, documented in the Campus Antisemitism and Student Experiences (CASE) report (I served on its advisory board), took place on a Canadian university campus.
What Happened to Competition? Why Sovereignty Is the Wrong Answer to Quebecor’s Bid for Telus
Rogers v. Rogers, the exceptional one-person play, recently ran in Ottawa, giving attendees a chance to relive the battle over control of Rogers and competition law’s role in Canada. Prioritizing wireless competition seemed like an obvious policy position at the time, but it appears to have been short-lived. This week, Quebecor unveiled a $31 billion proposal to acquire Telus, which, if completed, would reduce the number of national wireless carriers from four to three and unwind the very remedy the government relied upon to justify approving the Rogers-Shaw merger in 2023. Industry Minister Mélanie Joly released a Telecom Competition Roadmap less than three weeks ago that declared “cross-Canada competition” to be the government’s objective, but her statement on the bid refers to competition only in the name of the Competition Bureau. The statement still mentions prices Canadians can afford, but it says nothing about maintaining the fourth national competitor the government has repeatedly claimed was essential to making wireless prices more affordable. Instead, the new priority is “sovereign connectivity from sea to sky,” which doesn’t make a ton of sense as the organizing principle for the largest telecom transaction since Rogers-Shaw.
The Law Bytes Podcast, Episode 283: Sabine Witting on Why the French Constitutional Council Struck Down France’s Under-15 Social Media Ban
Bill C-34 heads to committee in the coming weeks, with the under-16 social media ban likely to be the headline issue. Canada is not alone in exploring this sort of legislative measure. France passed an under-15 age ban, but the French Constitutional Court struck it down weeks before it was set to take effect. That decision raised many of the same concerns aired in Canada.
Sabine Witting is a German lawyer and academic with over 10 years of experience in human rights, child rights and digital technologies. She’s examined the French decision and proposed new EU laws that continue to advance age verification requirements. She joins the Law Bytes podcast to unpack the French decision, talk about age verification and smarter regulatory design requirements, and consider what may lie ahead in France and the broader EU rules.
Back-of-the-Napkin Cultural Policy: The Government’s $600 Million Streaming Plan Copies the CRTC Decision It Killed at More Than Double the Cost
The government quietly released details on Sunday of how it will allocate the $600 million it promised in June when it announced plans to kill the CRTC’s Online Streaming Act ruling on Internet streamer contributions. The plan largely copies the CRTC’s 2024 base contribution decision, with public tax dollars replacing streamer contributions at a rate far higher than the Commission expected. The windfall is seemingly another by-product of a policy the government is making up as it goes along: cancel the CRTC decision and use back-of-the-napkin math for $600 million, then rely on the same CRTC decision for allocations with the public paying cultural groups far more than the streamers would have been required to contribute. The government plan, booked for a single year ending in March 2027, notably includes $91.5 million for the broadcaster news funds that the streamers have been fighting in court. Five months after the bombshell decision, the government still has not released its promised policy direction to the CRTC, yet it has adopted the Commission’s framework for how it will divide the money.


















