Articles by: Michael Geist

Patent by Brook (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0) https://flic.kr/p/3fKqYy

The Law Bytes Podcast, Episode 160: Peter Carrescia on Why Patents Won’t Solve Canada’s Innovation Problem

In recent years, there has been growing effort to link longstanding concerns about Canadian innovation with patents. The argument – which has crossed into Canada’s strategy around AI – posits that the road to an innovative economy is inextricably linked to a greater emphasis on intellectual property and in particular on patents. But what if the correlation between patents and innovation is weak at best? What if an emphasis on patents may actually be harmful to startups whose attention and resources is better placed elsewhere?

Peter Carrescia is a successful innovator and investor who recently wrote a Globe and Mail op-ed that raises precisely these issues, warning that “creating policy that pushes patents regardless of area or company stage and gauges success by counting patents is misguided and, in fact, dangerous to the success of startups.” He joins the Law Bytes podcast to talk about his experience and concerns with direction of government policy that may be mistaking an IP policy for an innovation one.

Read more ›

March 20, 2023 6 comments Podcasts
Welch-McCarthy-Hearings, United States Senate, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons, https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f1/Welch-McCarthy-Hearings.jpg

Government-Backed Motion Demands Disclosure of Years of Third-Party Communications With Google and Facebook in Retribution for Opposing Bill C-18

The government plans to introduce a motion next week requiring Google and Facebook to turn over years of private third-party communication involving any Canadian regulation. The move represents more than just a remarkable escalation of its battle against the two tech companies for opposing Bill C-18 and considering blocking news sharing or linking in light of demands for hundreds of millions in payments. The motion – to be introduced by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Canadian Heritage (yes, that guy) – calls for a series of hearings on what it describes as “current and ongoing use of intimidation and subversion tactics to avoid regulation in Canada”. In the context of Bill C-18, those tactics amount to little more than making the business choice that Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez made clear was a function of his bill: if you link to content, you fall within the scope of the law and must pay. If you don’t link, you are out of scope.

Read more ›

March 17, 2023 21 comments News
Rodriguez screen shot, House of Commons, May 30, 2022, https://parlvu.parl.gc.ca/Harmony/en/PowerBrowser/PowerBrowserV2/20220530/-1/36984

Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez Contradicts His Own Bill and Department Officials in Effort to Defend Bill C-18

Canadian Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez is on the defensive as he tries to defend Bill C-18 in the wake of both Google and Facebook signalling that they may remove Canadian news from search results and social media sharing in light of the government’s approach that creates mandated payments for links. Rodriguez appeared on CBC yesterday and had no answers for the questions about what he will do if the companies walk away from news given government estimates that they could be on the hook for 35% of the news expenditures of every news outlet in Canada if they continue to link to their news content. More notably, he contradicted both his own bill and his own department officials when he told Postmedia that “C-18 has nothing to do with how Facebook makes news available to Canadians.” For those who followed months of gaslighting with Bill C-11, this comment will provide a sense of deja-vu since Rodriguez sometimes leaves the impression has only read media lines, rather than his own legislation.

Read more ›

March 14, 2023 14 comments News

Nuanced: Michael Geist on the Importance of Freedom of Expression Online

I appeared on the Nuanced podcast hosted by Aaron Pete on March 15, 2023. In the episode, we discussed Bills C-11 and C-18 and how Canada’s internet-regulation agenda could affect creators and users. The link to the episode is here.

Read more ›

March 13, 2023 Comments are Disabled ExtPodcasts, Video

The Dean Blundell Show: DBS One On One with Professor Michael Geist On Bill C-18/C-11

I appeared on the The Dean Blundell Show on March 16, 2023. There, I discussed Bills C-11 and C-18, including their potential impacts on internet regulation, freedom of expression, and digital content creation. The link to the video can be found here.

Read more ›

March 13, 2023 Comments are Disabled Video