News

Macleans on C-32 & Fair Dealing: Claims of Rampant Copying “Grossly Exaggerated”

Macleans education blog has a post on Bill C-32 and the extension of the fair dealing provision to education.  The post gets beyond the misinformation campaign to set the record straight: “the claims that the addition of education as a fair dealing category will lead to the erosion of the […]

Read more ›

December 9, 2010 38 comments News

Sorting Through the Copyright Levy Proposals

The Canadian Private Copying Collective appeared before the C-32 Legislative Committee on Monday, leaving Access Copyright and the CACN with secondary roles as MPs devoted most of the discussion to the levy issue. While the levy vs. tax characterization discussion came up, it seems to me that there will be mounting confusion over the competing levy proposals.  The CPCC made their pitch, but there are now multiple proposals for extending the levy or creating entirely new levies (some varations are supported by the same organizations).  The key proposals:

Read more ›

December 8, 2010 43 comments News

“Canadians told us the TPM provisions in C-61 were too far reaching”

According to documents I recently obtained under the Access to Information Act, this quote was part of a draft speech for Canadian Heritage Minister James Moore.  The quote was removed by department officials before approval of the final version.  Moore delivered the speech in June 2010, in which he proceeded […]

Read more ›

December 8, 2010 10 comments News

CBC’s The National on C-32

CBC’s The National ran a good story on Bill C-32 over the weekend, focusing specifically on the impact on consumers.

Read more ›

December 7, 2010 48 comments News

The Wikileaks Copyright Cables: Confirmations Not Revelations

Last weekend, I posted that I suspected the KIPR tag on U.S. diplomatic cables being released by Wikileaks represented cables involving intellectual property issues.  Sure enough, the first batch of KIPR cables have been released in Spain, confirming U.S. pressure on that country to reform its copyright laws.  The release – which come from El Pais – has generated considerable commentary with BoingBoing proclaiming that it reveals that the U.S. wrote Spain’s proposed copyright law.  That headline led others to speculate what the remaining KIPR cables might reveal, particularly the 65 Canadian ones (there are also 84 WIPO tagged cables and nearly 2,500 KIPR tagged cables overall).  There has been one release on copyright law in France, with officials discussing U.S. industry support for its three-strikes approach.

While I am very interested in seeing the Canadian KIPR cables, I’d be surprised if the cables reveal anything new.  The fact that the U.S. is actively lobbying in foreign countries on intellectual property issues (particularly copyright) is not a secret, it’s a open strategy.  The cables don’t really show that the U.S. wrote Spain’s copyright law, because they didn’t need to.  Years of relentless lobbying pressure at the highest levels of government make it as clear as possible what the U.S. is looking for (plus they release the annual Special 301 report just in case anyone is still confused) so that when a government decides to reform its laws it invariably takes the U.S. position into account.

Read more ›

December 6, 2010 35 comments News