Post Tagged with: "social media ban"

Woman holding a smartphone with app icons displayed by Swello, Unsplash licence, https://unsplash.com/photos/woman-holding-a-smartphone-with-app-icons-displayed-ylc0PEMBME8

The Law Bytes Podcast, Episode 283: Sabine Witting on Why the French Constitutional Council Struck Down France’s Under-15 Social Media Ban

Bill C-34 heads to committee in the coming weeks, with the under-16 social media ban likely to be the headline issue. Canada is not alone in exploring this sort of legislative measure. France passed an under-15 age ban, but the French Constitutional Court struck it down weeks before it was set to take effect. That decision raised many of the same concerns aired in Canada.

Sabine Witting is a German lawyer and academic with over 10 years of experience in human rights, child rights and digital technologies. She’s examined the French decision and proposed new EU laws that continue to advance age verification requirements. She joins the Law Bytes podcast to unpack the French decision, talk about age verification and smarter regulatory design requirements, and consider what may lie ahead in France and the broader EU rules.

Read more ›

November 16, 2026 — 1 comment — Podcasts
Coffee Hall Chinatown signage by Nathan Dumlao, Unsplash licence, https://unsplash.com/photos/coffee-hall-chinatown-signage-hJuU7prVwog

Has the Government Read Its Own Bill? What Three Days of House Debate Revealed About Bill C-34 Before the Committee Hearings Begin

Bill C-34, which would ban social media accounts for under-16s, is now before the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage, which just approved plans to hold at least 16 hours of hearings starting the week of November 16th. The government’s position on the bill became clearer during several days of debate last month at the House of Commons, revealing a shift in how MPs describe the ban (it’s now euphemistically called an “exemption model”), how they defend the decision to leave dozens of key issues to future regulations (one implausibly claimed that addressing all the issues would create a 1,500 page bill), and what they think of mandated age verification (some admitted to concerns about it). The takeaway was that the ban and the uncertainty in its implementation will be difficult to defend at committee.

Read more ›

November 5, 2026 — 4 comments — News
Guess my age by Devin Smith https://flic.kr/p/droNwy CC BY 2.0

Ofcom Did the Work Canada Plans to Skip: What the UK’s Age Verification Report Reveals About the Bill C-34 Social Media Ban

The most contentious aspect of the government’s Bill C-34 social media ban for under-16s is that millions of Canadians will need mandated age verification to create social media accounts. The bill tacitly acknowledges that this raises privacy concerns, as it includes a mandatory consultation with the Privacy Commissioner and leaves the future Digital Safety Commission to set the necessary standards. But as I wrote in June, the problem is that the government plans to bring the ban into force before the Commission even exists, meaning the age verification will proceed without established standards or the privacy consultation the bill itself requires. The United Kingdom, which is pursuing a similar ban with a spring 2027 start date, has adopted the opposite approach by asking Ofcom, its regulator, to assess what effective age verification would look like before Parliament sets the rules. The resulting report, released this week, is the most candid regulatory account of a social media ban to date. Ofcom identifies four methods capable of establishing whether someone is 16 or over and it finds that each of them requires using photo ID either directly or as the backstop given the ineffectiveness of age estimation for younger users.

Read more ›

October 30, 2026 — 7 comments — News
BAN'; by Sean Lamb https://flic.kr/p/52DbrG CC BY-NC-SA 2.0

The Wrong Ban: The Heritage Committee Backed a Targeted Ad Ban for Kids and Stopped Short of a Social Media Ban, Yet the Government Chose the Reverse

The House of Commons Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage conducted an extensive study on the effects of influencers and social media on children and adolescents over the past year and released its report in June. The committee, which will soon lead the review of Bill C-34, produced 13 recommendations including a legally enforceable duty of care, an independent regulator with monetary penalties, safety-by-design requirements, defined categories of harm, and the inclusion of AI chatbots and deepfakes. Given the overlap with the government’s social media bill, it is no surprise that the government endorsed many of the recommendations this week. There is an outlier, however: the committee considered two potential bans, one on targeted ads for kids and the other on underage access to social media. The committee recommended the ad ban and stopped short of the social media one, but the government reversed the approach, declining the ad ban while legislating the social media ban for under-16s.

Read more ›

October 23, 2026 — 1 comment — News
man in brown jacket and white pants standing beside white and blue wall with blue by Smitty (@thetrentonsmith) Unsplash license, https://unsplash.com/photos/man-in-brown-jacket-and-white-pants-standing-beside-white-and-blue-wall-with-blue-and-0SGG-ttbuTw

Regulator First, Rules Later: Bill C-34 Debate Shows the Government Wants a Digital Safety Commission Before It Figures Out What It Will Do

Second reading debate on Bill C-34, the Safe Social Media Act, began yesterday in the House of Commons, with the government pressing opposition MPs on whether they support creating the Digital Safety Commission, its proposed Internet regulator. While there was some broad acknowledgement that someone needs to administer the regulatory plan, it was striking to see the government focus on the regulator rather than the regulation. Liberal MP Kevin Lamoureux asked Conservative critic Rachael Thomas whether “in principle, the Conservative Party recognizes the value of having such a commission” and later asked Bloc critic Martin Champoux whether his party sees “the principle of having that commission as a positive thing.” When Culture Minister Marc Miller was asked what standards a platform would need to meet for an exemption to the under-16 social media ban, he responded that the way to protect kids is “to make sure we have a regulator in place that can put together precisely these guidelines.” That is a bug, not a feature of a bill that, as I wrote when the bill was tabled, punts roughly 50 key decisions to cabinet and a commission that does not yet exist. The initial debate confirms that the government plans to build the regulator first and work out the details later.

Read more ›

October 22, 2026 — 1 comment — News