President of Ukraine holds meeting with Minister of Foreign Affairs of Canada by President of Ukraine, Public domain,

President of Ukraine holds meeting with Minister of Foreign Affairs of Canada by President of Ukraine, Public domain,


“A Lack of Commitment to Transparency and a Failure of Leadership”: Melanie Joly and Global Affairs Ignore Information Commissioner Ruling in My Request for Decades-Old Copyright Records

In 2017, I filed an access to information request with Global Affairs Canada seeking records related to the creation of the WIPO Internet Treaties more than 20 years earlier. The timing of the request was not accidental. The exception for cabinet confidences in the Access to Information Act no longer applies after 20 years and my hope was to gain insights into the government’s thinking during the negotiation process that might have previously been publicly unavailable. The request took a long time to process and the department still withheld many records on a range of grounds. I rarely appeal to the Information Commissioner, but in this case I did.  Last week, the Information Commissioner determined that my complaint was well-founded, but Global Affairs and its Minister, Melanie Joly, have thus far refused to abide by the ruling.

The Information Commissioner recommended the release of most of the information at issue, yet the government seemingly won’t comply. According to the decision:

On August 31, 2023, I issued my initial report to the Minister of Foreign Affairs setting out my recommendation. I also asked the Minister to give me notice as whether she plans to implement my recommendations and, if so, what specific actions she would be taking in that regard. The Minister of Foreign Affairs did not give me notice whether she would be implementing my recommendation. It is very regrettable that Global Affairs does not take its obligation under the Act seriously and, in addition to ignoring the complainant’s right of access, ignores the Act’s requirement to respond to my initial report. This is a clear sign of a lack of commitment to transparency and a failure of leadership.

I have the right to apply to the Federal Court for review. While I consider that option, the failure of the Access to Information system becomes even more readily apparent. These records are literally decades old and have now been the subject of years of review. The Information Commissioner rightly notes that the department exhibits “a clear sign of a lack of commitment to transparency and a failure of leadership.” For a government that once campaigned on greater transparency, failing to abide by its own (inadequate) law sends a discouraging signal on its respect for access to information and undermines efforts to encourage the governments of other countries to commit to transparency.


  1. Sadly this is not unexpected. There were many complaints about government reluctance under the Harper government, and it has only gotten worse under the current government (according to the Information Commissioner). Both governments, while campaigning, had promised to be more transparent, but in power went the other way.

    • As a student Or Jobless, finding flexible work opportunities that can be done from the comfort of your own home is essential. Whether you need to earn extra money to cover your expenses or gain valuable experience in your field of study, freelancing can be a great option. ei In this article, we will explore the best online platforms for finding freelance work as a student Or Jobless.
      Explore Here…………..

  2. I am sorely disappointed in our government. Same behavior as the previous government, which tells me that all of them are a bunch of lying thieves that cannot be believed or trusted. Canada deserves better!

    What are they so scared of in those 20 year old documents? Now we really need to push by all means and find out.

  3. Just more campaign lies. How do you know a politician is lying? His lips are moving.

  4. Working online brings in $285 dollars an hour for me. My best buddy shows me how to do this and makes $29,000 a month doing it, but I never realized it was real. Visit the following link to have.

    look at it…………………….

  5. The article is very well written. It will help everyone who uses it, including myself age of war game

  6. Numerous residents in Peregian Beach express a desire to thoroughly cleanse their residences, yet frequently face constraints in terms of time and equipment to execute a thorough job. Additionally, they recognize the inherent hazards associated with certain tasks like cleaning gutters or roofs. House Washing Sunshine Coast is available to provide assistance. click to learn more. Our group of exterior cleaning specialists in Peregian Beach is dedicated to rejuvenating your home, regardless of its size. Our house cleaning services in Queensland are of the highest caliber, and you’ll witness the transformative impact of a thorough cleaning, spanning from the roof to the foundation.

  7. We are looking for unemployed or part-time boys and girls for data entry jobs. The shift lasts from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m.and from 1:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. – public holidays from Saturday to Sunday.You will work from home. Training will be provided. ws data is entered into online portals. The salary for this position is $30,000.
    Join the team here…….

  8. best article I’ve read so far. I hope you write more article so I can learn more. I’m going to wait for more in the future.

  9. Artikel yang paling bagus yang pernah aku baca.

  10. I’m very to find this website and it’s helpful content. please write more content in the future. fujiwin88

  11. orabelle hana says:

    Great article. I read this blog all the time and I’m impressed. I think this information is very important, especially the last part. I have been trying to find this information for a long time. Thank you and good luck 2048 game