The stories shock as much for their frequency as their cruelty. A Jewish secondary school student reports that a classmate said he wanted to build a gas chamber and chain up Jews. Another describes classmates and teaching assistants making Holocaust jokes. Yet another was told “welcome to your gas chamber” by someone who noticed their Star of David in a campus bathroom where people were vaping.
My Globe and Mail op-ed notes that these three incidents and hundreds more like them paint a picture of antisemitism in education systems at levels not seen in decades. The secondary school student report appears in a recent British review, which found that three in five Jewish pupils between the ages of 16 and 19 had experienced or witnessed antisemitism and that about half of incidents go unreported. The student reporting Holocaust jokes is taken from a task force study at the University of California, Los Angeles, and the “welcome to your gas chamber” incident, documented in the Campus Antisemitism and Student Experiences (CASE) report (I served on its advisory board), took place on a Canadian university campus.
Since Oct. 7, 2023, independent reviews of antisemitism in education have been conducted in Britain, the Netherlands, Australia, France, Sweden, and U.S. states such as New York and Massachusetts. The findings around the world are strikingly similar, with recurring reports that Jewish students often hide their identity, fear coming forward to file complaints, and distrust equity and anti-bullying frameworks that rarely account for antisemitism.
Governments have tended to respond quickly to their own reports. For example, the British government accepted all 27 of the recommendations from its commissioned report the same day it was released. Australia agreed to every recommendation of its parliamentary inquiry and has since established a Royal Commission, and France enacted new legislation just over a year later.
Beyond government-backed reviews, university-commissioned studies yield similar findings but produce discouragingly different outcomes. In Australia, every university adopted a common definition of antisemitism in early 2025, but a government assessment a year later found none had written it into enforceable rules.
At Toronto Metropolitan University, a damning report by former Ontario Court of Appeal Justice Mary Lou Benotto, commissioned by the university, was first delayed, then released with redactions, and then referred to another committee that will review the review instead of acting, with an implementation strategy not due until next year. Concordia University’s antisemitism subcommittee resigned when the university refused to publish its findings separately. Institutions committed to discrimination-free learning environments seem unable to act on their own reports.
The Canadian record is particularly troubling. The House of Commons Justice Committee recommended a national review of campus antisemitism, but it was never conducted. One study commissioned by the former federal Special Envoy on antisemitism documented 781 incidents in Ontario schools, nearly one in six of which involved a teacher or a school-sanctioned activity, with almost half of those reported to school authorities never investigated. A second found that 95.7 per cent of Jewish students surveyed reported experiencing or witnessing antisemitism in the previous year and 70 per cent said their university did not take it seriously. The Special Envoy’s office was abolished in February, six months before the campus study was released.
This leaves governments to use the regulatory and financial power that universities and school boards cannot ignore. Australia’s antisemitism envoy issued a new report last month that identifies the drivers of antisemitism, including what it calls modern, progressive antisemitism, and has established a university report card to name and shame those that fail to act.
Universities Canada recently responded with a five-point plan calling for a national response, stronger enforcement, and better data, though it includes no definition of antisemitism and no timeline. Nolan Quinn, Ontario’s Minister of Colleges, Universities, Research Excellence and Security, has signalled his impatience with the lack of action, issuing an updated university directive in September that puts funding at risk for systemic failure to act. The directive has potential, but it also lacks a definition of antisemitism or a deadline for compliance.
The numerous studies on antisemitism in education confirm both that there is a global problem and that universities and school boards have proven incapable of fixing it themselves. Governments must therefore shift from identifying the problem to asking why those institutions are failing to respond. Provincial governments should commission independent reviews of education system responses to antisemitism, and the federal government should restore the Special Envoy’s office with the mandate to ask what is happening to Jewish students and the power to hold institutions publicly to account.










