Eight Tech Law Issues To Watch in 2008

Predicting the future of Canadian technology law is challenging at the best of times, but with upcoming national elections in the United States and possibly Canada, prognostications for the next twelve months are admittedly likely to be about as accurate as a coin flip. With that caveat in mind, my weekly technology law column (Toronto Star version, homepage version) returns by offering up eight issues to watch in 2008.

Security Breach Reporting Rules Are Introduced.  Scarcely a week went by last year without a report of a security breach that placed the personal data of thousands of Canadians at risk.  Last spring, a House of Commons committee acknowledged that the country needs mandatory security breach disclosure legislation that would require organizations to advise Canadians when they have been victimized by a breach.  A public consultation on the issue concludes next week and new regulations will be introduced before the summer.

CRTC Injects Itself Into New Media Regulation Debate.  The CRTC last addressed Internet regulation in 1999, but the issue will be back in the spotlight in 2008.  The Commission will release its preliminary thoughts on new media regulation in March, followed by public comment and hearings.  The public will recoil at the prospect of government regulation, but some cultural groups will welcome increased intervention.

Copyright Reform Heats Up.  The issue that dominated discussion late last year will heat up again once Parliament resumes. With tens of thousands of Canadians speaking out on copyright, Industry Minister Jim Prentice is in the unenviable position of facing competing pressure from the U.S. government, copyright lobby groups, and the general public.  Launching broad public consultations would be the optimal approach from both a policy and political perspective, however, look instead for a copyright bill in early February and very heated Industry Committee hearings throughout the spring.

The iPod Levy Takes Centre Stage.  The private copying levy, which has generated more than $200 million for musicians and the music industry over the past six years, will continue to face public criticism and legal scrutiny.  The Federal Court of Appeal hears arguments on the extension of the levy to the iPod later this week in a case that could ultimately end up at the Supreme Court of Canada.  If the courts uphold the levy, consumers and retailers will demand that the Conservative government follow through on its 2005 policy pledge to eliminate it.

The Do-Not-Call List Takes Effect.  After years of dithering, last year the CRTC took much needed steps toward launching a do-not-call list, setting the basic ground rules and awarding management of the list to Bell Canada.  Once operational, millions of Canadians will register their phone numbers within a matter of weeks, but then express disappointment when the large number of exceptions – which includes political parties, polling companies, charities, newspapers, and businesses with a prior relationship – undermines the list’s effectiveness.

Canada Finally Gets Anti-Spam Legislation.  The National Task Force on Spam recommended introducing anti-spam legislation in 2005, yet successive governments have puzzlingly placed the issue on the backburner.  Anti-spam legislation will make its way onto the legislative agenda in 2008 as Canada becomes the last major developed country to take legal steps to counter what now constitutes 80 – 90 percent of Internet service provider email traffic.  

Net Neutrality Concerns Mount But Politicians Do Not Respond.  Net neutrality, which has been simmering as an issue in Canada over the past three years, will reach a boiling point this year as leading ISPs implement traffic throttling technologies that undermine the reliability of some Internet applications and experiment with differing treatment for some content and applications.  Despite consumer concerns, politicians and regulators will do their best to avoid the issue.

The Canadian Digital Divide Expands. With no government involvement in sight, the Canadian digital divide will expand in 2008.  The largest ISPs will continue to introduce faster fiber to the home for a handful of customers in urban centres, but leave many rural communities stuck on the Internet slow-lane.  Given the importance of the Internet on political participation, broadband connectivity will emerge as a surprise election issue in some parts of the country.


  1. Chris Brand says:

    Can you provide a link to the security breach consultation, please ?

  2. What about ‘lawful access’? I was sure that would be on the list.

  3. What about introducing something against the extortionate cell-data plans?

    If and when the iPhone comes to Canada, there will likely soon follow endless stories of naive consumers with multi-thousand $$ data bills. We’ve seen a handful of these stories here already, but I bet they snowball once the iPhone gets here, unless Rogers updates their data plan.

    Canada needs to get with the rest of the world (incl a lot of 3rd world countries) and provide data plans for a 21st century cell phone.