Rogers v. Rogers, the exceptional one-person play, recently ran in Ottawa, giving attendees a chance to relive the battle over control of Rogers and competition law’s role in Canada. Prioritizing wireless competition seemed like an obvious policy position at the time, but it appears to have been short-lived. This week, Quebecor unveiled a $31 billion proposal to acquire Telus, which, if completed, would reduce the number of national wireless carriers from four to three and unwind the very remedy the government relied upon to justify approving the Rogers-Shaw merger in 2023. Industry Minister Mélanie Joly released a Telecom Competition Roadmap less than three weeks ago that declared “cross-Canada competition” to be the government’s objective, but her statement on the bid refers to competition only in the name of the Competition Bureau. The statement still mentions prices Canadians can afford, but it says nothing about maintaining the fourth national competitor the government has repeatedly claimed was essential to making wireless prices more affordable. Instead, the new priority is “sovereign connectivity from sea to sky,” which doesn’t make a ton of sense as the organizing principle for the largest telecom transaction since Rogers-Shaw.
The disappearance of competition as the north star is striking when compared to Rogers-Shaw. I criticized that approval, arguing it undermined competition, but then-Minister François-Philippe Champagne at least framed the issue around affordability, competition, and innovation. The government has since argued that an independent fourth player (Quebecor, which scooped up some of Shaw’s wireless assets in the merger) helped bring prices down. Quebecor’s own announcement cites Statistics Canada data showing that wireless prices fell by 35.4 per cent between April 2023 and April 2026 as evidence of what the company accomplished after acquiring Freedom Mobile, yet it now proposes to merge with one of the incumbents. It says it will keep the Telus brands, but the Canadian experience with the incumbents’ flanker brands confirms that separate brands are not the same as separate competitors.
Joly’s statement is also silent on her role in the proposed deal. It points to reviews by the Competition Bureau and the CRTC and to processes under the Telecommunications Act, but says nothing about the Radiocommunication Act power over spectrum licence transfers that ultimately decided Rogers-Shaw. The Minister need not prejudge those reviews to restate the government’s commitment to a fourth national competitor. Joly has much to say about sovereignty, however. As the Globe’s Andrew Willis notes, she invoked it three times in a brief statement, language that seemingly mirrors the pitch Quebecor CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau says he made to Joly and Clerk of the Privy Council Michael Sabia in Ottawa last week, which he described as focused on the need for domestic telecom companies that can compete with Elon Musk’s Starlink. But since all four national players are Canadian, the merger would reduce Canadian competition without changing who owns Canadian networks.
Indeed, the evidence to date suggests that sovereignty is a red herring in this deal. Rogers, Bell, and Telus have all turned to foreign companies for their satellite-to-mobile services, and while Quebecor says it would turn to Canadian satellite networks, it isn’t clear why that would require reducing the number of national wireless competitors. If sovereignty is linked to resilience, the July 2022 Rogers outage is a reminder of the risks of relying on fewer networks.
The sovereignty playbook has been used before. For example, when Verizon contemplated entering the Canadian market in 2013, the incumbents launched a massive lobbying and advertising campaign built around fairness for Canadian companies. Verizon ultimately decided against market entry, leaving consumers with some of the highest wireless prices in the world and a lesson that the “national interest” in Canadian telecom is often a thinly veiled attempt to protect incumbents from competition.
Foreign investment has long been controversial. Canada dipped its toe in the water with the 2012 reforms, which lifted foreign ownership restrictions for carriers with less than 10 per cent of the market, leaving Bell, Rogers, and Telus as the only carriers still facing foreign ownership limits. I told a Senate committee at the time that the government should have removed the restrictions altogether. Telus is the most viable target for a foreign entrant, since unlike Bell, Rogers, and Quebecor it does not own television networks subject to the Broadcasting Act’s Canadian ownership requirements (its Optik TV distribution service might complicate the deal). Foreign ownership would still raise questions about national security and exposure to foreign legal demands, but new capital and a global entrant could significantly improve competition and lower consumer prices. If the government believes Canada needs better-capitalized carriers that can invest more in their networks, opening the door to foreign investment while keeping four competitors in the market is a better approach than allowing a Quebecor-Telus merger that does little more than undermine years of government emphasis on competition and consumer affordability.







