Entering Canada Sign by Jimmy Emerson, DVM (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0) https://flic.kr/p/cB7FRQ

Entering Canada Sign by Jimmy Emerson, DVM (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0) https://flic.kr/p/cB7FRQ


The Trouble with the TPP, Day 21: U.S. Requires Canadian Anti-Counterfeiting Report Card

This weekend, former Research in Motion co-CEO Jim Balsillie wrote a must-read opinion piece in the Globe and Mail on the TPP. Balsillie makes a compelling case for how Canadian IP policy has failed in light of decisions to consistently cave to foreign pressures:

Starting in the 1980s, Canadian policy makers and politicians blindly bought the narrative lobbied by foreign corporations, first in the pharmaceutical industry and then across all sectors, that stronger IP protection would lead to more domestic innovation and prosperity.

Three decades later, our pharma R&D has declined dramatically and drug prices for Canadian consumers are among the highest in the world. Our largest technology companies are much smaller now than 10 years ago and we have zero growth in innovation outputs over the past 30 years.

We should have learned our lesson by now, and yet the same outdated thinking from the 1980s is back on display from today’s TPP proponents: Focus on aligning our domestic IP laws with the U.S. system and hope for the best. TPP needs to be assessed not for its legal purity or alignment to U.S. laws, but for the economic impacts colonial IP policies have on Canada. After all, Canada has aligned its laws with the United States both directly and indirectly in several international treaties over the past three decades, and our innovation performance always faltered thereafter.

The Trouble with the TPP series has already reviewed how the TPP offers more of the same through policies such as copyright term extension and locking in extended patent protections. The agreement also addresses IP enforcement and border measures, just months after Canada changed its rules to provide more protections and enforcement.

For example, Article 18.76 of the TPP seeks to expand the power of customs officials by granting them the right to initiate border measures without court oversight, even for goods that are in-transit (ie. not destinated to stay within the country). The in-transit issue was a major source of U.S. lobbying during the debate over Bill C-8, Canada’s anti-counterfeiting bill. Canada ultimately excluded in-transit shipments from the ambit of the bill with the government arguing that “our government doesn’t believe taxpayers should be on the hook for the cost of seizing counterfeit products that are destined for the United States that do not threaten health or safety.”

The U.S. hoped to reverse Bill C-8 through the TPP.  In-transit seizures are mandated in the agreement, but footnote 122 in the TPP states:

As an alternative to this subparagraph, a Party shall instead endeavour to provide, if appropriate and with a view to eliminating international trade in counterfeit trademark goods or pirated copyright goods, available information to another Party in respect of goods that it has examined without a local consignee and that are transhipped through its territory and destined for the territory of the other Party, to inform that other Party’s efforts to identify suspect goods upon arrival in its territory.

With the “endeavour to provide” requirement, this provision appears to be another best efforts provision that is not a strict requirement. Yet the U.S. wanted a clear requirement from Canada and apparently demanded a side letter between the two countries:

Each government shall provide to the other, on a semi-annual basis, a compilation of notifications provided to the other government’s customs administration under footnote 122 of Article 18.76.5(c), highlighting description and quantity of the suspected infringing goods.  Finally, representatives of both governments shall meet upon the request of the other government to discuss any aspect of this agreement.

I have the honor to propose that this letter and your letter of confirmation in reply, equally valid in English and French, shall constitute an agreement between our two Governments, subject to dispute settlement under Chapter 28 of the TPP Agreement, which shall enter into force on the date of entry into force of the TPP Agreement as between Canada and the United States.

In other words, the Canadian obligation is not optional. The U.S. is requiring Canada to provide a report card every six months on its customs activities, meet on the issue whenever the U.S. demands, and face the possibility of a dispute settlement complaint for failing to comply with these rules. While some might view this as a modest requirement, the U.S. does not require similar reports from anyone else. Rather, consistent with the history articulated in Balsillie’s piece, Canada is once again bullied into complying with U.S. demands on intellectual property laws and enforcement.

(prior posts in the series include Day 1: US Blocks Balancing Provisions, Day 2: Locking in Digital Locks, Day 3: Copyright Term Extension, Day 4: Copyright Notice and Takedown Rules, Day 5: Rights Holders “Shall” vs. Users “May”, Day 6: Price of Entry, Day 7: Patent Term Extensions, Day 8: Locking in Biologics Protection, Day 9: Limits on Medical Devices and Pharma Data Collection, Day 10: Criminalization of Trade Secret Law, Day 11: Weak Privacy Standards, Day 12: Restrictions on Data Localization Requirements, Day 13: Ban on Data Transfer Restrictions, Day 14: No U.S. Assurances for Canada on Privacy, Day 15: Weak Anti-Spam Law Standards, Day 16: Intervening in Internet Governance, Day 17: Weak E-commerce Rules, Day 18: Failure to Protect Canadian Cultural Policy, Day 19: No Canadian Side Agreement to Advance Tech Sector, Day 20: Unenforceable Net Neutrality Rules)


  1. The more we can turn away from US style intellectual property law, the better. It’s backwards thinking and designed by control freaks. Their entertainment industry also has way too much control and has even taken down foreign corporations over copyright such as Megaupload. Canada needs to tell that industry to take their antiquated practices elsewhere and strip all that nonsense from the TPP.

  2. Hello there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this website before but after
    reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me.
    Nonetheless, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be book-marking
    and checking back frequently!

  3. Pingback: Canada bullied into complying with U.S. demands in TPP | Ecocide Alert

  4. I pay a quick visit daily some web pages and blogs to read
    articles or reviews, except this blog offers quality based posts.

  5. I believe that is among the most important information for me.
    And i’m glad studying your article. However wanna remark on few common issues, The web site style is wonderful, the articles is actually
    nice : D. Excellent activity, cheers

  6. Ɗoes your website havbe a contact рage?
    І’m Һaving troouble locating іt Ƅut,
    I’Ԁ like tо ѕend
    ʏօu аn е-mail. Ӏ’νе got some recommendations fοr
    ʏοur blog уߋu might ƅе іnterested іn hearing.
    Either way, ɡreat site and І loօk
    forward tо ѕeeing it develop оѵеr time.

    Ӎү webpage: Manufacturing & Metalworking Cnc Machines

  7. Hello, i think that i noticed you visited my web site thus i came to go back the want?.I’m trying to in finding issues to enhance my site!I guess its
    ok to make use of some of your concepts!!

  8. What’s up friends, its great piece of writing regarding teachingand fully defined, keep it up all the time.

  9. IDC data indicates sixty two% off smartphone users cheeck their phones immediately after waking up, while 79% test theirs within quarter-hour of waking up.
    With manufacturers struggling to eextend e-mail deliverability, the astlnishing SMS deliverability
    leaves no queestion that sms marketing services free (asiachinachina.com) marketing is a worthwhile funding.

  10. Thanks for one’s marvelous posting! I quite enjoyed reading it, you happen to
    be a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and definitely will
    come back from now on. I want to encourage you continue your great writing,
    have a nice morning!

  11. I am actually delighted to glance at this webpage posts which contains plenty of useful data, thanks for providing
    these statistics.

  12. Analizy użytkowników, obszerne statystyki lig europejskich, hokeja, tenisa, koszykówki, siatkówki,
    piłki ręcznej, MLB, sportów zimowych, sportów walki, darta,

    kolarstwa, polityki i rozrywki. Konkursy w którym do wygrania są darmowe depozytu legalnego bukmachera.
    Ciekawe artykuły, przemyślenie, baza linków, systemy bukmacherskie, systemy gry, bukmacherzy stajonarni, sts,
    toto-mix, fortuna, fortuna zakłady, obstawiane, jak obstawiać zakłady.

  13. Due to a strong economy and upcoming sporting events such as the FIFA World Cup
    and the Olympic Games, investment is on the increase all over
    Brazil. Back then, QNET offered exclusive high-value coins and medallions.
    Meanwhile, the three finalists for each category were announced on 6 December 2010.

  14. Kia and Hyundai are identified for their a bad credit score financing programs aand this may be
    something value trying into if a brand new car is what you are thining about.
    You could wish to name your native dealer to search out out about current rebates and incentives that
    you should use in lieu of a down cost.

    Feel free to visit myy webpage :: Infographics E-Commerce Review

  15. Atenção: este produto é um medicamento que possui nova concentração
    e nova indicação terapêutica no país e, embora as pesquisas tenham indicado eficácia e segurança aceitáveis, mesmo que
    indicado e utilizado corretamente, podem ocorrer eventos adversos
    imprevisíveis ou desconhecidos.

  16. thanks for the information on this blog, keep mailing expert depicted object thank you

  17. We’ll be back next time with more news and free apps for i – Pad,
    i – Phone and i – Pod touch. Your history is kept
    on file so you can see everything you have purchased and either
    relive the joy. Because of this, it can be hard to find the best apps available, but this article highlights three of the best tower defense
    CSR Racing 2 Hack.

  18. Oh my goodness! Impressive article dude! Many thanks, However I am experiencing difficulties with your RSS.

    I don’t understand the reason why I can’t join it. Is there anybody getting identical RSS issues?

    Anyone who knows the solution can you kindly respond? Thanx!!

  19. We have listed some tips that they average renter can use when their looking for another
    apartment. It’s a wonderful tool for both owners and those looking to buy or rent.
    Also look for the outlets for your cable and phone jacks.

  20. The recipient is unengaged to choose when to redeem the house.
    If you’re bugged up a prank caller or simply with some unknown number, use Cell Phone Reverse Lookup to trace down the source of these calls and add a sense of security in your life, regardless of whether it is a
    landline or cell phone number. Before you spend the large
    amounts of money that many of these health and beauty products costs, read our reviews on the
    various different items, even natural health and beauty ones, that
    are economical and can be used to achieve health and beauty at productreviewsonline.