Stop Hiding Behind the Phone Book, Mr. Toews
December 7, 2011
Share this post
2 Comments

Law Bytes
Episode 283: Sabine Witting on Why the French Constitutional Council Struck Down France's Under-15 Social Media Ban
byMichael Geist

November 16, 2026
Michael Geist
November 9, 2026
Michael Geist
November 2, 2026
Michael Geist
October 26, 2026
Michael Geist
October 19, 2026
Michael Geist
Search Results placeholder
Michael Geist on Substack
Recent Posts
Apples to Orange: Why Europe Doesn’t Make the Case for a Three-Player Wireless Market in Canada
Three Fixes for Lawful Access: Making the Case for Amending Bill C-22 at the Senate National Security Committee
Jewish Students Are Telling the Same Story Everywhere But Only Canada Refuses To Listen
What Happened to Competition? Why Sovereignty Is the Wrong Answer to Quebecor’s Bid for Telus
The Law Bytes Podcast, Episode 283: Sabine Witting on Why the French Constitutional Council Struck Down France’s Under-15 Social Media Ban

Phonebook
I suppose if he’s so insistent on likening it to a phone book, then like a phone book, Canadians should have the option to opt out and be unlisted.
The problem with the article
After a fashion, the article is correct.
However, some of her comments don’t make sense to me. In the not too distant past, say, before the widespread use of the Internet and when the current laws were crafted, the uses that she talks about over the internet toward the end of the article were done over the telephone system and therefore accessible to police with a wiretap authorization. It is only in the past 15 or so years that much of this has migrated to the Internet.
She is correct, however, about the bill’s attempt to make access to the customer information available without a warrant… although in this case I can see the point, even though I don’t agree with it, that the information typically looked for is what would be published in an Internet phone book, had such a beast ever been created.