While my column this week focused on Canadian ISP transparency, the BBC reports that similar issues have arisen in the UK, where the Ofcom Consumer Panel is trying to address concerns that consumers are being misled about broadband services.
ISP Transparency in the UK
3 Comments
Recent Posts
Privacy as a Fundamental Right? The Government’s Terrible Privacy Track Record Suggests Virtue Signalling Over a Genuine Commitment 
Taking Stock of Bill C-34: Five Things to Know About the Government’s Plan for a Kids’ Social Media Ban, Mandated Age Verification, and AI Chatbot Rules 
The Exemption Illusion: Why the Government’s Plan to Fast Track Bill C-34’s Kids’ Social Media Ban Means No Standards, No Privacy Review, and No Enforcement 
Unpacking Bill C-34: My Appearance on the Globe and Mail’s The Decibel Podcast 
Liberal MP: Lawful Access “Has Nothing to Do With the Privacy of People and Their Information”
BT’s secret child-porn blocklist
Hey, Michael — I’m with you 100 percent on ISP transparency, but I wonder how you square your endorsement of the principle with your support for BT’s secret list of child porn sites, which are silently blocked, assembled in secret, and not subject to public scrutiny or review? I’m a BT customer and I get a LOT of 404s for sites that I can reach on other networks — how much of that is misplaced blacklisting? How do I find out? BT claims it blocks 30,000 calls to its blacklist a day, right? How many of those customers are trying to reach legit sites that have been non-transparently blocked by BT?
BT’s List
Cory,
I don’t believe that I ever endorsed the BT list – I don’t know enough about it to do so. I did (and do) support the Canadian version (Childfind), based on their undertaking to provide appropriate safeguards and oversight. The transparency in this case comes from ensuring that the public is aware of the program, its impact, and appropriate judicial oversight to mitigate against the possibility of misplaced blacklisting.
MG
Misunderstood you, then
Sorry, Michael, I must have misunderstood you earlier; I found out about the list from you during our earlier conversation about the Canadian blacklist; I understood you to be saying that you felt that the success of the BT list was an indicator that the Canadian list would work as well.