The ACTA Threat to the Future of WIPO

When the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement was first announced in October 2007, my first blog posting on the issue was titled Is ACTA the New WIPO?.  I return to that theme in an opinion piece just published by the Swiss-based Intellectual Property Watch.  While the first part of the piece focuses on the ACTA transparency issues, the second half discusses the short and longer-term implications for the developing world and the World Intellectual Property Organization.  I note:

In the short-term, WIPO members can expect progress on Development Agenda issues to stall as ACTA partners focus on completing their treaty. Given the scepticism surrounding the Development Agenda harboured by some ACTA countries, they may be less willing to promote the Agenda since their chief global policy priorities now occur outside of WIPO.

The longer-term implications are even more significant. While it seems odd to conclude an anti-counterfeiting treaty without the participation of the countries most often identified as the sources or targets of counterfeiting activities, the ACTA member countries will undoubtedly work quickly to establish the treaty as a "global standard." Non-member countries will face great pressure to adhere to the treaty or to implement its provisions within their domestic laws, particularly as part of bilateral or multilateral trade negotiations. In other words, there will be a concerted effort to transform a plurilateral agreement into a multilateral one, though only the original negotiating partners will have had input into the content of the treaty.

Given these possibilities, I argue that the best course of action is for the developing world to demand a seat at the ACTA table.  In doing so, it would in fact turn the plurilateral negotiations into a multilateral one and thereby ensure that the ACTA better reflects the interests and concerns of the global community.  In particular:
With all the cards now on the table, the developing world faces a stark choice – remain on the ACTA sidelines and face a future filled with pressure to implement its provisions or demand a seat at the table now. Countries such as Mexico, Morocco, and the United Arab Emirates have all been part of current or previous ACTA negotiations, suggesting that there is little reason to exclude any country that wants in.

By bringing Brazil, Argentina, Chile, India, Egypt, South Africa, China, Russia, Indonesia, and a host of other countries into the mix, the ACTA would shift back toward a multilateral treaty and in the process ensure that the counterfeiting and piracy concerns of the global community are appropriately addressed. Moving the ACTA discussion into WIPO may not be happen, but it is still possible to imbue the negotiations with both transparency and broad participation from the developed and developing worlds.


  1. END of internet as we know it read and visit the sit eshow support
    how do you fell about usage based billing and caps

    help canada be unlimited

  2. Fallenlamb says:

    Salute your new masters!!!
    The points made in this piece are relevant. They are however minor flaws in the grand scheme of things. Data is now our live in a little stick, and to have anyone given powers to go through it without any oversight is simply nerve-racking. Try to imagine if you will how far we’ve gone with data in the last 10 years, what happens in the next 10 years? Does this mean when I cross the border, anyone has the right to go through my medical history just because it happens to be accessible on a laptop that I must bring across the border – according to ACTA is does!

    What about your sons or daughters photos on your computer? Is that really your son, or is it child porn? Who knows? Let’s take your Laptop for 3 months while we determine, in the meantime forget your livelihood!

    I think if this keeps up were going to have to put armbands on all border guards. Give them a special salute as we cross.

    We beat the Nazi’s, only to lose the war against the Capitalists. This world is becoming more depressing by the minute. Welcome to the new world order!

  3. United Hackers Association says:

    YOU don’t know what war is my friend
    they are getting dsmall tastes daily now.
    more and more the people wake up.
    more and more the sheep as you say become the wolves.

    The time is coming,

    hack the planet

  4. Danny Friedmann of IP Dragon says:

    Dear Michael,

    Indeed, ACTA seems to threaten the relevancy of WIPO, but especially WTO’s TRIPs.
    One innovation of TRIPs is that is can use the dispute resolution mechanism of the WTO. In other words TRIPs is WIPO plus teeth.
    How do you think the ACTA member countries will enforce ACTA itself? I have not read about who is going to interpret the provisions of the treaty.

    Danny Friedmann

    IP Dragon
    Gathering, commenting and sharing information about intellectual property in China to make it more transparent, since 2005